El Maguey Grill
El Maguey Grill things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Plan your stay
Posts
I think this place used to be good but is has gone severely downhill. As Gen Z would say, the food was just mid. Most everything was bland, lacking flavor and salt. I meant to order their chunky guac which is about $10.5 and instead I ordered creamy which was $4. The creamy guac definitely is not made fresh and likely comes out of a bag. I then ordered vegetarian option D or B with a bean burrito and cheese something or other. Everything was bland, not even the cheese saved it. I give 3 stars because it’s not like anything terrible happened like bad service or food poisoning. But the food is not good. Additionally, I have heard stories and read recent reviews that very small sides (sour cream, cheese, etc) they are charging $2.5 for. Whereas they used to be free or a small surcharge like 50 cents. With so many good places in Goshen and surrounding area, I will not be back anytime soon. Also, the menu the restaurant posted 1 year ago is still accurate.
Amanda MAmanda M
20
The food was tasty. No complaints on taste. Wife ordered the "little bit of everything". I ordered a mocajete. For appetizers we had the chunky guacamole and queso funido. The chunky guacamole was above par. The queso was average. Wife said her was good. My mocajete was flavored well and tasty. Only complaint on it was it was 85% bell peppers and cactus. What little meat was in there was tasty though. The picture in the menu didn't match what was delivered. Again the food was tasty. Service was fine as well. It was 2.19 for a side of sour cream. Which blew my mind. There was a buuuunch of flies everywhere. Overall it was average due to the flies and principal of being charged 2.19 for a tiny side of sour cream... Had there been more meat in the mocajete and a minimal charge on cream, We'd probably feel more enthusiastic.
Tim JoynerTim Joyner
10
While previous experiences with the burrito and chimichanga were positive, my recent visit unfortunately fell short. The fajitas were disappointing, with subpar meat and vegetable quality. The service was also underwhelming, as a requested side of hot sauce was replaced with a spicy red watery substance. The chorizo queso was particularly disappointing, with a texture that was unappetizing and unpleasant. Given these experiences, I hesitate to recommend the fajitas or the chorizo queso. While I’ve had positive experiences in the past, I’m concerned about the restaurant’s food handling practices and may reconsider future visits.
Corey SmolkaCorey Smolka
10
Nearby Attractions Of El Maguey Grill
Pam Chaney Aesthetics

Pam Chaney Aesthetics
5.0
(158)Click for details
Nearby Restaurants Of El Maguey Grill
Sports Time Family Pub & Grill
Don Jose's Mexican Grill & Cantina
Bruno's home of the 24” Pizza

Sports Time Family Pub & Grill
4.4
(507)Click for details

Don Jose's Mexican Grill & Cantina
4.4
(247)Click for details

Bruno's home of the 24” Pizza
4.0
(109)Click for details
Basic Info
Address
56028 Parkway Ave A, Elkhart, IN 46528
Map
Phone
(574) 522-1100
Call
Website
elmagueygrillelkhart.com
Visit
Reviews
Overview
4.3
(836 reviews)
Ratings & Description
attractions: Pam Chaney Aesthetics, restaurants: Sports Time Family Pub & Grill, Don Jose's Mexican Grill & Cantina, Bruno's home of the 24” Pizza
