Casey's Dugout — Restaurant in Evansville

Marketed as a boutique pizza place, you're definitely going to get boutique prices, so be aware of that. As of writing this review 5/13/2024 they have no phone you can call to order carryout, which I find lacking. I would rather call and place my order than having to go in and wait for my order. I didn't know they didn't have a phone number as the local review sites have stated they were open for carryout after googling and looking at their website and all reviews I decided I'd just have to drive over and place an order and wait. I was told when i asked if they would be getting a phone i was told hopefully next week. This review is for what I ordered on 5/11/24 Saturday I went early a bit after they opened, which was 3 pm. I entered, and the person taking the orders was nice. Be aware it is kinda hard to hear in there as it can be a bit loud with everything going on when you're placing an order. I ordered at around 3:40pm and had my order in hand and back to my car by 3:50pm. Didn't expect that at all. The place itself is clean and has nice decor. I love the theme, especially since I am a baseball fan. I ordered breadsticks x2, the potato pizza 10-inch (they just renamed it), and the field of greens 10-inch total with tip was a little over $50. First, the breadsticks loved those I like that they add the toppings. The potato pizza minus the bacon (we had taken off) was supposed to have sour cream or tzatziki sauce we didn't get either for some reason, so at home just added sour cream ourselves since we had it . I discovered this when I got home. The potatoes were nice and soft, and the pizza was ok. The field of greens was the better of the two. The ingredients were fresh which was great crust was good as well. Crust was nicely baked as well. Do I think its worth the price ? At this time for family and myself no. Maybe I'll give it another try and try different pizzas they do have a small variety of their specialities. This isn't a weekly pizza stop for us. I am glad i was finally able to try it i had been waiting for awhile. Also be aware there is only 4 parking spots if youre not from the area you will need to park across the street in the parking there becareful...

Title: A Slice of Heaven: My Encounter with the Best Pizza Ever!

Have you ever experienced love at first bite? Well, I have, and it happened the moment I sank my teeth into the delicious creation from Casey’s Pizza. Let me tell you, this pizza is not just your ordinary pie—it’s a flavor explosion that will leave you craving for more.

From the first glance, Casey’s Pizza exudes an aura of authenticity and passion. The aroma that fills the air as you walk into the shop is enough to make your mouth water. But it’s not until you take that first bite that you truly understand why Casey’s is in a league of its own.

The crust, perfectly crisp on the outside yet wonderfully soft on the inside, serves as the canvas for a masterpiece of flavors. Each ingredient, from the tangy tomato sauce to the gooey melted cheese, is carefully selected and expertly balanced to create a symphony of taste that dances on your palate.

What sets Casey’s apart from the countless other pizza joints in town is the attention to detail and commitment to quality. You can taste the passion and dedication that goes into every pizza they serve, and it’s evident that they take pride in their craft.

But beyond the amazing food, there’s something special about Casey’s that keeps me coming back for more. Maybe it’s the friendly staff who always greet you with a smile, or the cozy atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. Whatever it is, there’s no denying that Casey’s has something magical about it.

I have tried countless pizza shops in town, but none even come close to Casey’s. I have no doubt that with pizzas like these, Casey’s will continue to thrive and be incredibly successful.

So, if you ever find yourself craving a truly unforgettable pizza experience, do yourself a favor and head to Casey’s Pizza. Trust me, you won’t be...

We waited to try this place because there is never an open parking spot(there are only 4) and no phone to call in an order. This place has been open months, they obviously don't want a phone for good reason. A friend said he'd go, sit and wait for it even though he was annoyed. Had to park across the street and he was almost expecting his car towed by the time he got out. Thankfully didn't happen. Ordered a simple 16" sausage and pepperoni. He waited 20 minutes. Not a bad time to wait but the point is he shouldn't have to if they cared enough to actually have a phone. He did say the place is incredibly loud. Got the pizza and brought it back. I open it up and the smell of burnt was so overwhelming it made me gag. I think my kitchen light is being kind to the picture! THIS WAS BLACK! Who in their right mind would take this out of the oven and think it was ok to serve?? My friend is color blind and wasn't sure it was as black as it was when they gave it to him. We did try a bite. Completely inedible. The whole thing went straight in the trash. We then realized this is why they haven't gotten a phone. So people can't call back to complain. Neither of us wanted to go back, search for a parking spot, wait again for them to make it right if they even would. With no parking, loud atmosphere and an obvious lack of caring for what they serve, pass this place by! ...