Lyle's — Restaurant in Evansville

Horrible Horrible Horrible I've been ordering pizza and stroms from lyles for a long time but who ever the current cooks are seriously pathetic!!! Then they over charge me and got my order wrong 2 times when I called back a third time the cook told the bartender to tell me he was busy WTFFFFF if I wasn't trying to be a better person I would've went and threw this dang ole pizza all over the cook who told me twice I completely understand I got u!! I for sure will be calling the owner tomorrow to let him know how his patrons are being treated!!! Bunch of dick heads now I'm stuck with a pizza I won't even eat cause I don't...

We had a BLAST!

We're from St. Louis MO area and were in Evansville for me to have surgery. We just so happened to pass Lyle's whole. Looking for a place to get my hair braided and after looking at pics of the food on Google we decided to give it a shot! Absolutely thrilled we did. The had live music (right up our alley), good drinks, great food and jusg a good vibe/energy the whole time we were there 💜💜

No regrets: Food: OUTSTANDING Service: AMAZING (unfortunately didn't catch the bartenders name 😭 but we were there 4/10/25) Atmosphere: fantastic!

Will be back on one of the days I have to come back to Evansville...

Great pizza and Stromboli....need to clean the oven more often. Last Stromboli we got was covered in black stuff that looked like it came off the oven ways. Not real appetizing. Updating my review. Hadn't had a stromboli for a while so ordered one last night. Very disappointed. They started using a much smaller hoagie bun to make them on, and had about half the ingredients on it. And it cost $15.00. What a joke.....the Stromboli is a joke compared to what it used to be. Won't be going back...