Manhattan City Pizza — Restaurant in Florida

I stumbled on to this pizza shop by accident. It's actually pretty close to my family's home so that's a bonus, and they deliver so that much better. Now I have a few pizza shops that are around my home and we've tried them all. This place is hands down the best we've had around here. My family is old school Sicilian and I grew up with my grandmother Nona making pizza every year for new years eve, this pizza is so very close to my Nona's pizza it's scary good. Ironically they call it the grandma's pizza and it's delicious. Now the grandma's pizza is not as thick as a traditional Sicilian pizza but it's still square. The dough is not bready but it's got a little chew. It's thin and crispy but thicker than a standard hand toss pizza. It's like the best of Both Worlds when it comes to the grandma Pizza, it's like if the Sicilian pizza and hand tossed Pizza made a pizza baby this would be what came of it. Which is exactly the type of pizza my Nona made. Now that's just the dough. The sauce on the pizza was just as good. The sauce was fresh and flavorful as if my Nona jar packed all the fresh tomatoes for the year. The sauce tastes homemade with all natural flavors and sweetness of fresh tomatoes that were cooked down as if Nona herself had cooked the sauce all day for Sunday gravy. They even use fresh mozzarella for the cheese on top. I hate whenever pizza places use the fake cheese that makes everything greasy or rubbery. This place uses the real whole milk cheese that has a perfect cheese pull as their shredded cheese and fresh mozzarella balls that sit in water made fresh daily. I know this review seems long but it's because our family has been looking for great pizza for a long time that's close to our home, and when you finally find it then you really want to tell everyone. Well this is that pizza and it will now be our new favorite place to get pizza. Oddly enough we even got the Caprese salad which is just fresh mozzarella with tomatoes and basil and olive oil with balsamic, it's one of my dad's favorites. But even with that simple salad, that was even delicious. I knew it was good because my dad wanted all the rest of it and didn't want to share. But honestly it really was delicious and that's why it's a long review. I'd post a picture with this review but we all tore into it so quickly because it was just that good that there wasn't enough to take pictures.

Edit: still delicious but at least now I can post you a picture after I've had the first bite of course. You can get a true large foldable...

First time customer. My wife and I have been batting zero on pizza places....we hit the jackpot tonight. Eddie....the owner was fantastic. As my pizza as cooking he engaged in conversation and made feel as if we grew up together.....and he didn't have to do that. We talked food and how important it is to put the love into your cooking. And of course the pizza was absolutely delicious. Cooked to perfection and very flavorful! Eddie....my friend....my Brother....thank you for keeping it real and serving food with class and love. I've seen some not so kind reviews about your establishment and I totally disagree with them all. To everyone out there.....stop by....give Manhattan Pizza a chance. I really believe you'll not only enjoy.....but it will become a place you'd love to come back to. Not only has this become our No. 1 pizza choice.....it's officially our only one. See you...

I stopped here one time because I was starving and I was already in the plaza. I got a spaghetti with meat sauce and fell in love and now my family and I are there about once a week. Everything from the pizza to the spaghetti to the salad and garlic knots- their wings and jalapeño poppers are incredible. Their prices are fair and their attitudes and customer service is top tier. It’s so refreshing to step into this restaurant and be met with a great atmosphere and such a kind soul as the man that owns it. He’s always so thankful for us coming in and in a world so crazy and not so kind it’s awesome to see. We’ll continue coming here for years to come just because of the great people and great food! Thank you for all you guys do! And whoever makes that homemade spaghetti sauce deserves a quarterly...