The Bagel Shop — Restaurant in Homer

Wow — I’m still thinking about that bagel and lox sandwich! This bagel shop completely exceeded my expectations. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, and the smell of fresh-baked bagels filled the air — absolutely irresistible.

I ordered the open-faced bagel and lox sandwich, and it was a symphony of flavor on a plate. The bagel was fresh and perfectly made. Topped with silky lox, a generous spread of cream cheese, crisp red onions, capers, and fresh herbs — every bite was balanced, flavorful, and incredibly fresh. It was clear that every ingredient was chosen with care.

The people here take real pride in what they do. It wasn’t just a sandwich — it was an experience. Whether you’re a bagel lover or just in search of something truly special, don’t pass this place up. I’ll be dreaming about that sandwich until...

We came upon The Bagel Shop by chance, after walking out of another establishment disappointed because of how rudely we were treated by staff. Turns out it was the best thing that could've happened to us!

The place was hopping on a Sunday morning (unlike the other place, which should've been our first clue to move on), but staff still took the time to greet us with a friendly "Hello and Welcome!" as we walked in, which is something we didn't experience at the other place.

The menu was quite expansive, and everything looked (and smelled) so good! We ordered one of the specials as well as soup and salad. The Bagel sandwich was packed with yummy ingredients, as was the soup and salad. The flavor profile of everything was soooo good! We will definitely be patronizing this establishment...

This place was recommended by friends of ours and was one of the best bagel shops that I have eaten at. The quality of the ingredients was superb and it looks like they have a wide variety of different sandwiches to choose from!

We came in the morning for some breakfast bagels to go. I ordered a pork roll, egg and cheese on a garlic bagel. The pork roll was well seasoned and the cheese was all melty. The bagel had a great chewy consistency and the garlic wasn't overpowering. I also picked up an iced vanilla latte that was smooth and sweet. We also picked up a Reuben pastrami melt, a bacon, egg and cheese that was also well received. I will be coming back here...