Manhattan Pizza & Wings — Restaurant in Huber Heights

Ok, something new in Huber, great reviews, I really wanted to love this, but, read on. This was delivery so your dine in experence could be different. Ordering was fine, delivery was perfect, food portions are great. But, I think they need to tweak the taste some what. I ordered a XL works pizza, after opening the box, most of the ingrediants had melted to the center. One of the big reasons is the sauce. It looks like they use fresh tomato sauce, but, it's way to thin and watery, causing everything to slide to the center and completely slide off when grabbing a slice. Also the sauce doesnt have any flavor. I dont think it has any seasonings that I could taste anyway. I think they rely on the over salted pepperoni for flavor, and the peps just dont have any, other than salt. The crust never made it through the delivery process crunchy at all, very chewy with none of that Ney York crust zing. Bland and unseasoned. Next we had the Gyro. I wanted to love it, but when Arbies makes a better gyro, you get the picture. We also tried the wings that everyone praised so much in the reviews with some medium sauce. They were crunchy for sure, over done to be exact. Although, small, they were cooked to death, dry, hard, not very toothsom. as for the medium sauce, I'm not sure what planet this sauce comes from, but there was no sauce left on the wings when they arrived. Some watery liquid in the bottom, didnt taste like any wing sause I have ever had with little to no kick. If they used butter they didnt reduce it at all as it was watery. I didnt get the zing of vinegar or hot sauce. Bland, salt less and tasteless. So that about raps it up. To be fair, I think you get a good amount of food for you money, if your looking for volume, this is the place and also, I haven't tried any other dishes, they could have a sleeper dish that is awesome, but judging by the reviews, nothing really stood out. This place could be a real winner if they tweaked there recipes a little. There is a reason why chain pizza sauce is reduced down and zesty, there is a reason why BW3 sauce stays on the wings and is zesty. There is a reason why hundreds of gyro makers do a better job. I wouldnt take my word for any of this, I would defintly try it yourself and make a honest review and be open. But, also I think, this pizza place needs to be honest about taste and no that it isnt quite perfected yet. They might need to call in Gordon Ramsey. Lololololol.

Try it...

Just picked up my first ever order from Manhattan, and it was incredible. This will be my go-to from now on when I want to splurge for a pizza night. Easily my favorite between the Huber and Dayton areas. I ordered a large meat lovers, a 6 count bone in hot wing, and an order of fried cheese ravioli.

Starting with the pizza: Man, their crust and sauce are enough for me to spend a little extra to never eat at any other pizza spot again. I didn't think pizza crust could be THAT good. Plenty of great quality mozz and toppings as well.

The wings: These are the best wings I've had from any pizza place in the area and it isn't even close. I would happily come in just to grab a few wings. The sauce was great too. I can't pinpoint what ranch they use, but it was also delicious.

The fried cheese ravioli: These are hard to mess up. But they did have the perfect fry, and they were high quality. Plus, that marinara sauce could make anything 500x better.

My order was ready quickly after ordering, and the gentleman that handed it off to me seemed very kind.

I took my order to go, but I'd happily eat in the restaurant. It was modern and extremely clean inside.

If you are thinking about a pizza night, I promise you, it's worth the extra money to splurge for this kind of quality over the Dominos or Pizza Hut you're used to eating. Not to mention the copious amount of options they offer from stuffed shells, to burgers to eggplant rolls and many...

Wish I could give this place zero stars! I was a long time customer and use to love this place. I have no idea what happened but, the prices went up and the food quality went down. I don’t think they know the difference between ziti and spaghetti!!! My order is messed up every single time I order! And I am not exaggerating!!!! My receipt is right but my order is wrong. The Tiramisu is boxed and frozen. Not fresh at all. Last night I ordered and I asked for 1 spaghetti and 1 ziti. When it got here they were both ziti. I called and asked about the spaghetti and got no where!! I asked for a refund and didn’t get it. My husband ate his and I only wanted the refund for mine. So I hope they enjoy the $15 because I will never order from this place ever again!!! I didn’t want a refund on the whole meal, just mine. And nope! Even though he said he would refund the money on my card! Just be careful ordering the pasta dinners. They don’t know the differences in pasta. They also don’t know what no onion means. **edited to reply to comment left my Manhattan… my family has given you multiple times to get things right and it never happens. I’ve already spoke to the manager who could careless that my order was messed up for the 10th time!! And never got the refund he said I was gonna get. So your reply is...