Randy's To Your Door — Restaurant in Indianapolis

This is by far the BEST PIZZA I've had in Indiana and being from Florida, I would have to say this is the best quality, best value, most consistent, freshest ingredients, passionately made pizza I've ever had.

My family has lived in the Wanamaker Estates area since the late '50s and they have been ordering Randy's for ever.

I've heard about it all of my life but only got to try it for the first time about 5 months ago. I've gone and grabbed a pizza at least twice a month since! Great pizza, great service, great value, and great quality.

The 16" is huge and feeds my sister and I for at least three separate meals if not four with us each eating 2-4 pieces at a time!

I know there may be some not so great reviews about service, but we have NEVER had a bad experience. Just be kind, be patient, and have your order ready when you call and you will have a...

This spot is...let's just say "eclectic." "Randy's To Your Door" doesn't actually deliver. So, I thought that was odd. I've called several times (about 7-8 times total - various days, various times) and asked for delivery and I get "Uh, he's not here..." thus leaving only pick-up as an option. I was finally able to call again, get refused delivery again, but actually come pick the order up this time - it was slow enough at the shop that I was able to close down for a few minutes to go pick it up... Now, was it the absolute best pizza I've ever had? Not really - and I don't mean that disrespectfully. BUT, it was still pretty d**n good, though, and I would order again (for pick-up, of course). Just imagine your mama making you a pizza and that's what you get here. If you're looking for something different,...

Very bad experience. We decided to eat at Randy's and the issue we had was the place was locked up at 5:30 PM. Rang the doorbell several times and knocked on the door and someone finally showed up and said she was using the bathroom and couldn't get to the door. We ordered 2 small pizzas and we were told it would be 20 minutes and after 40 minutes I was so mad I wanted to leave. someone else came in while we were waiting and were able to pick up their order. The lady said that their order was before ours but couldn't tell me why she told me it would be 40 minutes when their was an order before ours. The service here really sucks. I won't...