Jersey Mike's Subs — Restaurant in Lavallette

Was craving a jersey mikes sub after seeing their numerous commercials guaranteeing freshness. Well.... epic fail. Ordered a whole tuna and provolone sub. 11 am in the morning and the roll was either day old or more. Tuna was very watery and had a bad flavor and lettuce was mildly wilting/ browning. The tomatoes looked good and girl making sandwich had a good attitude. Lets just say I can go a few more years before I get stupid again and return to a Jersey Mikes, especially this one in Lavalette.

For those craving a GOOD sandwich, white oak market on rt 35 in Seaside Park has fresh bread daily from a Newark bakery, and won't be $22 for a sandwich I can eat myself.

Jersey Mikes, you're one of the reasons I take my lunch from home everyday. Thanks for reminding me to keep...

This is an update to my previous review....I have went there twice since I was told there was new management and I'm happy to report that I had 2 excellent sandwiches. Thank you Jersey Mikes for actually listening.....

Where is the meat Mike? The picture is a roast beef, turkey and cheese. I really used to love the subs at Jersey Mike's, I live near this store and I'm so bummed because I'm done. I refuse to pay the prices for their skimpy little sandwich. They used to make such a nice sandwich , it's not just a random occurrence, they have been skimping all summer. Last week I ordered a number 7 with double meat just to see how much they would put on and it was a sandwich like they used to serve. It's really a shame that you have to pay for extra meat to get a decent...

I don’t usually leave reviews, but Jersey Mike’s was so perfect I have to share. The staff here genuinely cares — friendly, helpful, and always going the extra mile.

They accommodate guests in every way possible, making sure orders are exactly how you want them. They even offer free water without you having to ask — it’s those little touches that show they actually value customers.

The place runs like clockwork — fast service, clear communication, and an atmosphere that makes you feel welcome the second you walk in. I’ve been to many sandwich shops, and this is by far the most professional, well-run crew I’ve ever seen. Five stars all the way — you should definitely come.

How does this place not have a five...