Casey's — Restaurant in Lebanon

We were in there last night we were the only folk around 😂 felt nervous as heck. We went in there and then we asked a lot of questions about eating places and that guy at the cash register was so freaking patient with us he was so nice we looked at the pizza and we asked questions and we end up leaving going across the street we walked over there into the restaurant we walked in there and we felt immediately like we were not invited and they just wanted us to leave and one of the guests gave me a really nasty look so after we found out they did not serve chicken wings we left. We went back to Casey's and let me tell you we felt good about our purchase whoever that young man was on April 17th 2024 whoever those two young men were that worked that evening shift I think they need to work there a lot more because they made us feel so welcome they made very like perfection pizza they were very nice they weren't lazy I just I'm impressed big time that's the best that we've been treated since we've been close to Illinois Indiana and I don't mind ever getting lost again and going back to that Casey's thank you so much for treating us like people and not a race not like we don't belong thank you for giving us making us great pizza and make it us feel welcome thank you...

I used to go to this Casey's all the time. I enjoyed the people who worked here and I enjoyed the pizza. But now the people I always see are just rude. Most look at you without acknowledging you or a simple smile. The worst is whoever the older woman with short blondish grey hair and glasses. She should not be in a customer service position. I don't know if she's this way with everybody but to me she just has a mean mug face and just stares at you. I say hello to her and she says nothing back. I tried to give her .11 cents so I could get an even dollar amount back to which she ignored me 5 times. Then finally she looked up pissed off and confused on the math. I always say thank you and she always ignores me. I will drive across town to the other Casey's or go to a different gas station from now on. Until there's upbeat happy people or at the very least that woman who clearly hates her job and possibly her life not working there. I don't know why I try to be friendly to her knowing everytime she rings me up she's just rude. If a secret shopper came they would for sure not like that type of experience...

I don't usually rate business but I just moved back to Lebanon. Before I left you changed cooks and you had one of the best breaded tenderloins in town. When your cook changed your food went to the dump. I would like to know that has changed and you have a good cook before I start buying food there again. My husband used his app to order food in a regular basis and it was right before we moved to Crawfordsville (around 4th of July) the cook had changed. We now live back in Lebanon and hope things are back to the way they were. If you do not respond we know not to order there again. I will change my rating to 5 stars if the food is good again. And I will also change the wording in my rating. There is no excuse for burning the tenderloins. It happened 2 times so we stopped ordering then moved for personal reasons. But like I said, we're back and would like a good tenderloin now and then and the cheesey potato puffs. The thin pizza is excellent but the tenderloins were better. Let us know if you got it back together. I'm sure we are not the only ones...