Carlys Cakery — Restaurant in Ligonier Township

HONEST REVIEW,

CARLY IS A HOME BAKERY. SHE IS TALENTED IN DESIGN. SHE WILL ACCEPT ALL ORDERS, EVEN WHEN THE ORDERS FOR DESSERTS ARE MORE THAN SHE CAN MANAGE. IF YOUR ORDER IS NOT DURING A HOLIDAY OR BUSY TIME IT MAY BE GOOD.

BUT IF YOURS IS ONE OF SEVERAL, YOUR CAKE WILL BE MADE WELL IN ADVANCE AND SIT OUT AT ROOM TEMPERATURE AND NOT BE FRESH.

SHE IS NOT INEXPENSIVE. TO SPEND THAT MUCH MONEY ON A CAKE (OURS WAS FOR THANKSGIVING) AND HAVE IT BE DRY AND NOT EDIBLE WAS DISAPPOINTING AND WASTEFUL. IT WAS ALSO EMBARRASSING TO WATCH EVERYONE AT THE DINNER WE WERE INVITED TO LEAVE THE DESSERT WE BROUGHT, UNEATEN AFTER A FEW BITES.

I RESPECT ANYONE WHO IS TRYING TO MAKE A BUSINESS FROM HOME WITH CHILDREN, BUT SHE SHOULD ALSO BE HONEST ENOUGH TO NOT ACCEPT MORE ORDERS FOR CAKES THAN SHE CAN HANDLE.

WILL...

Carly made this unusual and unique groom’s cake for my son’s wedding this past summer. He was joking around and said he wanted an actual Thanksgiving dinner as his groom’s cake. He didn’t mention another thing about having a groom’s cake after that. He was so surprised when he saw the cake. Carly was amazing to work with and her artistry is amazing. She also made petite fours and sugar cookies with a picture of their pet bunny on it as another surprise for the wedding. I highly recommend...

I have gotten several cakes and cookies from Carlys Cakery, and I have never been anything but 100% pleased! I've thrown her some real curve balls with my cake requests, but Carly always joyfully accepts the challenge. I've actually "invented" a few occasions just to get one of her cakes! I love the personalized attention I get; you won't find better customer service anywhere. Do you know what else you won't get at other places? To-die-for...