Geneo's Pizza — Restaurant in Livingston

Parking was fairly spacious when I visited this restaurant on a Friday evening. I found parking when I visited a few months ago for the first time as well (another Friday evening, I think?).

For my first visit, I had a small one topping pizza (pepperoni) and nearly finished it. It was a very well-made pizza, one of the greatest I had at a local establishment. For my second visit, I tried the Chicken Pita sandwich with fries. My sandwich consisted of soft white bread pita, plenty of chopped grilled chicken, small jalapeno slices (discs?), and lettuce. The sauce inside the pita sandwich tasted like a creamy chipotle spread (I have no idea, but I know it's delicious). The Chicken Pita was a good size and I can see myself ordering it again.

The restaurant was nicely air-conditioned. With plenty of items on the menu and an arcade section that feature crane games and air hockey, you're likely to find multiple families dining in and as a result, hear plenty of commotion. So, this restaurant isn't ideal for a quiet place to dine (but who eats pizza quietly, anyway?). Of course, you can always order your food ahead of time...

Used to come to Geno's as a kid so wanted to check it out to see if it was as good. In one word...no. Items ordered: pizza sandwich, Ortega burger, and a dozen mild wings. Pizza sandwich was ok initially, but gets soggy really fast, so I ended up just eating the toppings and leaving the gooey pizza sauced bread. My mom had the burger and it looked disgusting. Instead of a whole green chile, like it's supposed to be and how they used to serve it in the past...now it's chopped up green chili. Between that and the fact that they put mustard on it, it looked like barf. Their saving game was the wings. They were crispy and barely sauced, and they bring out a tray with the sauces so you can add however much you want. I would go for the wings again for sure. Another issue here that cost them a star is that NONE of the items ordered came out at the same time, which makes it awkward and inconvenient. I had to ask if the wings are ever going to be served. All in all, I'll go back for the wings, and might try the regular...

Really upset they post salads at 3.69 online and pizzas at 16 so I show up ready to spend 20 or 23 dollars but at the register they tell me it's $35 after they had me wait half an hour. Really upset, will never return because we own a business and if my company on any level had prices posted I'd honor them and then explain about next time it would be different but to make a dad and his kid wait 30 minutes for food then refuse to honor what is publicly showing for your prices..... that's where I got upset.

Did not even offer to match the posted price, could have at least had a sale and a few repeat visits, I mean that was my second visit in 3 nights and I have a month here with a 15 man crew. Really surprised at this because I had really like the manager/owner lady...