Finn McGoo's Public House and Eatery — Restaurant in Mequon

I hate leaving bad reviews, but this was the worst restaurant experience I've ever had - and based on comments from other diners and the stream of people walking out, our experience wasn't unique. It was a bad sign when they only had one menu for our table (which we then passed on to the table next to us, as they had none). After 15 minutes, we finally met our waitress. After 30 minutes, we got our drinks. After 45 minutes we were brought a plate of bread and garlic mayo, and a promise that our food was coming. After 55 minutes, we went up to the bar so we could get more drinks (we had little faith they would ever be brought by our server). After an hour we got our appetizer - severely undercooked potato skins with huge hidden chunks of raw onion. Finally, after an hour and 15 minutes we got our entrées; in hindsight, I wish we wouldn't have. The fish fry was just not great - tasteless coleslaw, potato pancakes with a very weird texture, and dry fish. But the highlight was the reuben - it was moldy! I didn't even ask for a new one - decided to just cut my losses. Not sure how this place is in business. If possible, I would have...

This is a GREAT place. If you want a real Irish experience, this is the place to go!!!!! Finbar puts on one helluva show every Friday night at 9pm. He’s a talented musician, singer, and storyteller. He also performs with Norrah and Brock Mason. A definite “must see” performance. On a side note, Google currently has the hours of operation wrong. So, pending the correction, here they are:

Monday-CLOSED Tuesday-3pm-2am Wednesday-3pm-2am Thursday-11am-2am Friday-11am-2am Saturday-11am-2am Sunday 11am-6pm

Come check the place out. Amazing food, great atmosphere. They’re also adding a game room with dart boards, drinko plinko, shuffleboard, and they’ve also got Yard Yahtzee and bean bags for their outside patio. It’s a great place to have fun, eat, drink, and be merry!!!!!...

Not a good experience and we will not return. One waitress in the dining area and we had to wave a hand to get her attention. No water offered. Waited a long time to get a drink. One menu which we had to pass on to the next table . Neighboring table found the cutlery and passed it on to other tables. Waited a LONG time for food. Ordered a two piece fish dinner, but only one piece was fish. The other was batter only. While we were there 3 tables got up and left before placing an order. Not a good sign for your establishment. I would not recommend...