Rusty Pelican Miami — Restaurant in Miami

A Perfect Anniversary Celebration

My husband and I chose Rusty Pelican Miami in Key Biscayne to celebrate our anniversary, and it was truly an unforgettable experience. From the stunning waterfront ambiance to the exceptional service and incredible food, everything exceeded our expectations.

Ambiance & Atmosphere

We opted for outdoor seating, which was absolutely breathtaking. The view of the water and passing boats, combined with the outdoor fireplace, lounge chairs, and soothing music, created the perfect romantic setting. It felt like a getaway from the busy city —elegant, relaxing, and vibrant all at once.

Service

The service was impeccable. Our server CESAR C. was incredibly attentive and professional, ensuring we had a seamless dining experience. A great example of their excellent service was when our Caviar Frites arrived missing the caviar and its condiments. As soon as we brought it to their attention, they promptly replaced it with a fresh and perfectly prepared serving, which was absolutely delicious.

Food & Drinks

Every dish we had was a culinary delight: • Caviar Frites – A luxurious take on French fries, crispy and flavorful, especially once the toppings were properly included. • Seafood Tower – A beautifully presented and generous selection of oysters, shrimp, sushi, sashimi, and a lobster tail. The seafood was incredibly fresh and full of flavor, making it a highlight of our meal. • Chardonnay Wine & Rum and Coke – My Chardonnay paired perfectly with the seafood, crisp and refreshing, while my husband enjoyed his classic Rum and Coke. • Café con Leche Lava Cake with Ice Cream – A perfect sweet ending! The rich, warm lava cake combined with the creamy ice cream was decadent and indulgent—a must-try dessert.

Valet Parking

We used the valet parking service, which was quick and efficient. The standard valet was $9, and though there was a priority option for $20, we didn’t need it as our car was retrieved promptly after dinner.

Final Thoughts

Rusty Pelican provided us with a flawless anniversary dinner experience, from the stunning ambiance to the delicious food and outstanding service. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just looking for a great meal with an unbeatable view, this restaurant is a must-visit in Miami.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5/5 – Highly...

Best parts of the experience were the views and our server, Justin who was friendly, knowledgeable and attentive to our needs was awesome and if you decide to go you should request him. The not so great part was the food presentation, the quality of the food and the prices.

The bread that was served was corn bread with jalepino butter. Not bad but not my favorite either. The bread was too sweet for me especially as a start of a meal. We asked for plain bread and butter and were told they did not serve that. WHAT?

A few people ordered salads, which we thought would come as a starter. BUT they ended up coming with the MAIN COURSE!????? Still not sure what that was about. The smoked tomato salad was mushy with no crisp to it…it was loaded with dressing in the center which made for soggy lettuce.

The main courses came quickly but my steak came looking sad and lonely on a black plate with nothing but 3 roasted garlic cloves on the plate. Not sure if they were there to add flavor or to show you there was something on the plate. The meat blended completely in to the plate. Besides that, it was cold! A ribeye steak should come sizzling not lukewarm warm.

The Chilean Sea Bass on top of white mashed potatoes and again blended in with nothing to create an enticing plate.

The sushi looked good and was good I was told

The mashed potatoes that I ordered were cold but our server Justin was quick to bring fresh hot ones as soon as I mentioned it to him. He saved the day on that.

The French fries my daughter ordered were also cold and hard and tasteless however Justin came to the rescue again with fresh hot fries.

With the average being about $75 to $90 per person with appetizers and entree and a side dish (ie - mashed potatoes, fries or a vegetable), before tax and tip and with only 2 people having an alcoholic beverage and nobody had dessert….not a great experience and we will not be running back...

Veronica, Vic, and their food cronies, including the ultimate foodie Swampy, had the pleasure of visiting the Rusty Pelican before attending a Florida Marlins game. Swampy, known for his love of food, was particularly thrilled with the dishes he encountered at the restaurant.

Swampy couldn't resist indulging in the Chomp, Chomp! Seafood tower, which showcased an impressive selection of fresh and delicious seafood. The tower featured a variety of delectable options, satisfying Swampy's seafood cravings and allowing him to experience the flavors of the ocean in a unique and exciting way.

In addition to the seafood tower, Swampy was delighted to discover the Rusty Pelican's sushi offerings. The sushi selection offered a fusion of traditional and innovative flavors, expertly prepared by the chef. Swampy savored each bite, appreciating the artistry and craftsmanship that went into creating such a delectable dish.

Swampy also had the opportunity to try the Cuban sandwiches at the Rusty Pelican. Known for their rich flavors and cultural significance in Miami, the Cuban sandwiches at the restaurant were a standout. The combination of tender roasted pork, ham, Swiss cheese, pickles, and mustard on perfectly toasted bread created a mouthwatering culinary experience.

Swampy, along with Veronica, Vic, and their cronies, highly recommend a visit to the Rusty Pelican when in Key Biscayne. The restaurant's prime location, stunning views, and exceptional blend of flavors make it a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts. Whether you're craving seafood, sushi, or iconic Cuban sandwiches, the Rusty Pelican promises to deliver a memorable and satisfying...