Godfather's Pizza Express — Restaurant in Michigan City

All these reviews with 1 and 2 stars are just silly. The place is brand new, there's bound to be some hiccups and employees getting overwhelmed.

Now on to the meat and potatoes of my review: it tastes exactly like it did when they were located in Dunes Plaza over a decade ago. High-quality ingredients piled high. Made me feel like I was a teenager again.

We ordered the Humble Pie for us and a sausage for the kids. They were fresh, hot, and delicious.

Yes, the prices are higher than they were in 2009 when they left Michigan City previously, everything is more expensive now! I felt like the value was still there.

Overall, highly recommend. Don't let the negative Nancy's discourage you, it's...

Ordered 2 pizzas online and the wait time was 50 minutes!! Figured I would give it a try, waited and arrived exactly 50 minutes.....and they said they just recieved the order!?!? Wanted me to wait while they make it....I told them I already waited over 50 minutes. Had all the excuses (short handed) When I asked for a discount the manager offered my additional food for free? Dont have the hands but you want to prepare more??? Ended up walking out! All i can say is we still do not have a Godfathers in MC anymore. I will...

I understand that this shop just opened, it will take time for everything to come together. The crew was overwhelmed and unorganized. I ordered a classic combo, it didn't taste like the Godfathers pizza I am accustomed to it didn't really have a taste. I used to get a Godfathers pizza in Chesterton at a golo station and it was excellent. I think they may have changed ingredients in Michigan City. I will give it another chance in...