Navesink Fishery — Restaurant in Middletown Township

We have eaten here many times and we know what to expect. The food is good, fairly priced, service is spread thin, but usually satisfactory and the place is noisy. Recently we ordered our appetizer and entries at the same time. Imagine our surprise when they brought them all to our table together. We explained to the waitress that we wanted time to enjoy our appetizer and please bring the rest of the food later. Less than 5 minutes later, they returned with our dinners, one of which was so cold as to be barely edible. We complained again to no avail. There was no offer of free dessert (which we would have refused) and no offer to adjust the bill. Also they have a very bad habit of swooping down to remove empty dishes while the other person is still eating (which we do not permit).

Overall a quite...

If you’re looking for the freshest seafood in Jersey you have to come check out the navesink fishery! everything is fresh never frozen or from a can, right from ocean to plate and you can really tell in every dish. At this Mom and Pop vibe restaurant, the staff and atmosphere will make you feel like you came for a warm meal at your favorite grandparents house and treat you as one of their own. the flavor on these dishes is unreal and everything is handcrafted from the owner who makes sure things are running smoothly every night in the kitchen. come stop by if you are looking for a 2lb crab meat stuffed lobster or, simply a warm cup of homemade...

Wish I could give 6 stars!

Incredible ... incredible food. Reasonable price. Staff is extremely attentive and very friendly.

The calamari couldn't be better. It was hands down the best I've ever had. Comes with 2 sauces, one of them is a Wasabi dipping sauce. I would put it on everything.

Steamers were perfect! Oysters were ridiculously fresh. 🔥

The linguine with white clam sauce was phenomenal. My wife had a shrimp pasta dish - that was fantastic as well.

I cannot say enough about this restaurant to do it justice. Clean, well run, organized, amazing food, friendly staff.

It's one of...