Miltonian Pizzeria & Wing House — Restaurant in Milton

Ordered 2 pizzas, staff was courteous and attentive. While waiting they proceeded to have a discussion about the lack of stock for one of the ingredients I had requested on one of the pizzas as though I weren't standing directly in front of them. I expect they would have, eventually, said something too me. However, after a good 3-5 minutes of debate over what to do about this dilemma, I interjected asking if I could expect that topping to be missing. Upon recovery from the shock of learning I was not a deaf mute and was, in fact, capable of understanding the complex situation as presented they consulted with me as to a possible replacement. I, unfortunately, do not know if they loaded the pizzas up because of the lack of my requested ingredient, but both pizzas were piled with my requested toppings. The crust was perfect, crispy shell with warm chewy inside without being super bread-y. perfect proportions of cheese::sauce. It was the best pizza I'd had in years and despite my seemingly flip description of the cashiers/waitstaff, they seemed genuinely distressed over not having the topping I'd ordered, and that communications had broken down to the point that such a mistake could be made. If I'm ever in Milton again, I'll stop by again for more pizza and maybe an...

The place has gone significantly down hill in the last couple of years. The place is clearly not in its prime. The staff are arguing in plain view of the customers while the manager or owner mills around acting intimidating and aggressive more than anything. There was no ambient music or sound and place was less than welcoming .

Tonight their credit card machine went down. Rather than the restaurant posting this anywhere they did not tell us until we were seated and our order taken. From the staffs tales, the card was down before we came in. They chose to wait and try to force us into paying cash after scamming us into eating here.

The staff we rushing us out and sweeping under our feet while we waited for our pizza at the sit down portion of the restaurant.

The female owner operator manager was incredible. She turned around our bad experience with an up beat personality and was a light in the darkness for this restaurant. It is clear she cares and her presence changes the atmosphere significantly.

The food particularly the pizza was excellent. Hot, crunchy thin tall crust and flexible yet...

Oh how I love love ❤️ Miltonian! Their food, their staff, their owners! Found this place when I first moved to Delaware and it has be a frequent favorite years and years later! As a wing connoisseur I can say that Miltonian hands down has the best wings and wing sauce ANYWHERE! In all my travels the sauce is SPECTACULAR! So wish it was bottled and for sale! Pizza here is fantastic and all the dishes are made with true regard for flavor and freshness! Just cannot say enough good things! A community loving restaurant with genuinely kind people. I love visiting and the owner always takes the time to greet me by name ❤️ This place gets it right and checks all the boxes for me and my family! If you haven’t tried already…..get over there and grab yourself some wonderful food...