Classic Slice
Classic Slice things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Plan your stay
Posts
5 Pizza by the Slice in Milwaukee! What kind of slice are you getting? #MilwaukeeWisconsin #MilwaukeeLocal #MilwaukeeFoodies #PizzaByTheSlice
jmattmkejmattmke
1.9K49
First time visiting this place was strongly recommended my friend so I figured I’d try it out! Big mistake! I had order 45 minutes ahead of time , it Was supposed to be one of the best place for organic pizza! Walked in the place about 330 in the afternoon on a Wednesday. There wasn’t a soul in the place, so I stood there for like 10 minutes before anyone could come to the front desk ! Finally, this lady came out and say I’m sorry, but I didn’t see you! She brought out my order , when I looked at my pizza It was all burnt from the top. I mentioned this to her and she said they would take another 45 minutes to make a new one. So I said forget it. I’ll just take off the burnt and eat it, so I took it home. Except for my surprise when I got home it wasn’t only burnt on the top. It was also burnt on the bottom as you can see in my pictures. I wouldn’t eat in this place ever again even if they pay me! of course this cost me $18 too much for the quality of the food! never again!
Sam VSam V
00
I can't say enough about this place! You can order pizza by the slice or by the pie here. Note that the slices are gigantic, and one slice is more than enough to eat. All the slices are made to order here, so you will not see any pizza slices sitting around that are then heated up once you order them. You'll find the standard (sausage, pepperoni, cheese) pizzas on their menu, but the specialty slices/pies are the way to go! Why not show your true Wisconsin colors and add cheese curds to your next slice? My new favorite is their Detroit style pepperoni. It's tough to find Detroit style in Milwaukee, and they do a really good job of making theirs. I live close by and will definitely be back soon! If you're ordering pickup, I'd definitely call ahead as this place is very popular and can get very busy, especially Friday - Sunday evenings.
Jacob JohnsonJacob Johnson
10
Not your standard pizza place. First the pizzas are amazingly eclectic, but all balanced in flavor..from pesto pine nut to Meatallica meat lovers to Satryacon garbage feta toped deliciousness. I have been coming here for years and dine in or carry out, you will not go home without a seriously uniquely flavored pie or pizza by the slice (big slice). It has a rebel vibe with writing and stickers all over the place, with old school video games, and board games to entertain yourself. Limited seating outside; a few picnic tables. Bare bones awesomeness. Light on the beer selection but you come for the pizza. Every time I'm in Milwaukee, this is potentially a stop. They even have a point system to earn free slices and plenty of parking across the street.
joe mjoe m
00
The pizza here is just phenomenal! We travel almost an hour for this place because it’s that good. It’s my favorite pizza place in the whole Milwaukee area. I see some reviewers saying theirs was burnt, but judging by the photos they’ve shared, I’m pretty sure they’re just used to national chain pizza rather than fresh, real pizza like Classic Slice. Those little crispy charred bits and bubbles are gold! My family’s vegetarian with stints of veganism, and there’s something for everyone here. The pesto pizza is wonderful, something about the pine nuts is just amazing. I think it’s how fresh they are? They’re so flavorful. I just had their “400” pizza for the first time, and it is possibly my new favorite thing on this earth 😅
Min SiegelMin Siegel
10
Been going here for a decade. It's awesome. Reading some of the bad reviews I can't help but think if you find the service here rude or lacking maybe look in the mirror? It's one of the most chill friendly places on KK. On occasion it's crazy busy. Because it's good. It's worth the wait even on days they're slammed. Edit: I saw in the news the barstool sports guy being a big L to the staff on the one day they're closed for a staff party. They even let him in for a beer and gave him a cookie after he pretended to be really important. If this place could get a 6/5 I would give it Pizza places should review the barstool sports guy...
Nick RutkowskiNick Rutkowski
50
Nearby Attractions Of Classic Slice
South Shore Park
South Shore Park
Avalon Atmospheric Theater by the Neighborhood Theater Group, LLC
Avalon Atmospheric Theater
Humboldt Park
G. Groppi Food Market
Kinn Guesthouse Bay View
South Shore Farmers’ Market
ALTAR
Cupertino Park

South Shore Park
4.7
(987)Click for details

South Shore Park
4.7
(967)Click for details

Avalon Atmospheric Theater by the Neighborhood Theater Group, LLC
4.7
(549)Click for details

Avalon Atmospheric Theater
4.7
(548)Click for details
Nearby Restaurants Of Classic Slice
Honeypie Cafe
The Vanguard
Tenuta's Italian Restaurant
Hungry Sumo
Anodyne Coffee Roasting Co. | Bay View
Crafty Cow - Burgers & Fried Chicken
At Random
Goodkind
South Shore Terrace Kitchen & Beer Garden
Palomino Bar

Honeypie Cafe
4.5
(1.1K)Click for details

The Vanguard
4.6
(749)Click for details

Tenuta's Italian Restaurant
4.7
(728)Click for details

Hungry Sumo
4.7
(650)Click for details
Basic Info
Address
2797 S Kinnickinnic Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207
Map
Phone
(414) 238-2406
Call
Website
classicslice.com
Visit
Reviews
Overview
4.6
(761 reviews)
Ratings & Description
Description
Counter-serve pizzeria offering gourmet pies & slices in a hip, casual space with arcade games.
attractions: South Shore Park, South Shore Park, Avalon Atmospheric Theater by the Neighborhood Theater Group, LLC, Avalon Atmospheric Theater, Humboldt Park, G. Groppi Food Market, Kinn Guesthouse Bay View, South Shore Farmers’ Market, ALTAR, Cupertino Park, restaurants: Honeypie Cafe, The Vanguard, Tenuta's Italian Restaurant, Hungry Sumo, Anodyne Coffee Roasting Co. | Bay View, Crafty Cow - Burgers & Fried Chicken, At Random, Goodkind, South Shore Terrace Kitchen & Beer Garden, Palomino Bar
The Hit List

- Please manually select your location for better experience