Kellyo's Pizza — Restaurant in Mount Carmel

Time and time again we have placed orders with specific instructions, pick it up and take it home, only to find we did not get what was ordered. This time it was supposedly a mis-read of "no peppers", which somehow got read as "pepperoni" ANY other pizza place would have offered a free pizza or to make another at no charge. But because HALF the pizza was right we were told they only owed us half a pizza! But yet we were only actually offered $4 off our next. That doesnt even cover half the coat of the party size we bought!!!! Sure we should have learned to check the order before walking off or even paying, but we shouldn't have to. Add to this....it tasted awful tonight....not sure if it is a change in supplier or what...

I don't get the hype. The pizza was bland, toppings are far from fresh (canned), wings were terrible, and the "breadsticks" (which are Bosco sticks) were about the better thing (which ain't saying much) we had from here. Their marinara tastes like tomato soup. I don't know where all these other reviews are coming from but this pizza is at best, drunk worthy. The wings were broiled with the hot sauce on them which just burns the sauce not to mention frozen wings in top of that. I don't ever leave reviews but with this place I was seriously a let down. I was really looking forward to eating here according to the reviews. I am not trying to sound prude, but I would rather eat pizza hut or Casey's...

I can't believe that I waited almost 3 years to try their awesome Pizza. This is by-far the best thin/flaky crust with air pockets around the edges. (my favorite !!) The sauce has just the right "kick" without being weak or overpowering... It's the BEST Pizza I've had since I left Minnesota !! It beats Pizza Hut, Little Italy's and Bobe's to death with a sledgehammer -...