Johnny Jr's PIZZA — Restaurant in Netcong

NOTE: PIZZA RATING ONLY My family and I have ordered from every pizza place, franchise and mom & pop, in the area and Johnny Jrs. is BY FAR the best in our opinion. We order from Johnny Jrs. about once every other week and they have never disappointed us. The pizza is consistently delicious; the crust is not too thin or thick, perfect sauce/cheese ratio, and always perfectly cooked. And although I do agree with some of the other reviews that the portions could be bigger, I would much rather have a really good smaller slice than a 1/2 inch bigger, under cooked, sloppy mess (e.g. DON'T ORDER FROM DINO'S!!); QUALITY OVER QUANTITY. Again, I can only speak for the pizza, as we have not had their entrees or sandwiches, but with their pizza being so good, I can't imagine the entrees being any less. The appetizers we've had were also very yummy; mozzarella sticks, mac & cheese bits, fried calamari & ravioli (my husband & daughter love the fried raviolis!); and the zeppolis, not only do they give you a TON per order but are absolutely delicious. I would also like to mention one more thing that I personally find very VERY important: The majority of the mom & pop pizzerias have extremely rude employees (e.g. CARMINE'S has HORRID staffing) and the staff at Johnny Jrs. is always SO nice. From the man who answers the phone to both delivery drivers, everyone has always been very polite and courtesy. Little things, such as speaking to your customers, seem too often neglected, so I really enjoy ordering from Johnny Jrs. Who wants to work hard all day then treat yourself to an easy dinner only to talk to a total snot on the phone? Not this full time working mommy & wife. Johnny Jrs. comes HIGHLY recommend from the Kiely...

10/24/2024 I used to get there food all the time and loved it. 2.5 -3 years later after covid and some teeth issues I went today for the first time. Omg the cook and same man at counter was so unhappy and rude to me and the slices I got were so over cooked and burned at the bottom I literally took one little cut off the plain slice and couldn't even chew any of it. I also got a chicken bacon ranch slice it was so stale and hard it literally couldn't bend. I got a side salad and asked for shredded cheese. I was charged extra for dressing. I paid 16.98 for 2 slices and a small garden salad. The lettuce was partially brown. The best part was the fresh bread I dipped it in the ranch I had to pay for. The pizza crust on the bottom tastes like they added glass shards on it. They used to have almost like a little fried breading on it but it's so hard now it rips your tongue and roof of the mouth apart and it's so unappetizing. The slices so thin and barely any cheese. I will never go here again. Ever. If you want friendly faces and great food go to Franks on Hopatchung Rd. I. Hopatcong.

We just ordered from Johnny's again tonight and are on our way to pick it up. Since we moved here a year ago we used the slice app to try different places to eat. Johnny's is our absolute favorite!! My husband says they are always friendly no matter how busy they are and I can attest to the fact the food is always fresh and amazing if you ever do have something to ask for different they always accommodate if they can. Amazing staff and cooks can't go wrong. Out of the neighboring 5 pizza places this has become...

I called last night to place an order for pick up. One of the worst customer service experiences I've had with a restaurant. When I called and say "hi, can i place an order for pick up?". The response I recieved was "Ugghhh I guess so!", told her my pizza order, and was then asked "want anything else?" Spoken with attitude. I said "yes, do you have any garlic knots?" Her response was rude again, she only stated "6 or 12". I drove over and waited inside the restaurant for my order. While I was waiting I noticed the person who took my order kept, pulling her mask away from her face to talk to co workers, and then I saw her drink whiskey from one of those small Jack Daniels shot bottles (check your cameras for proof). She stated to another customer she was Johnny's roommate. Extremely unprofessional. On a recent previous visit, she had the same demeanor so I know this was not a one...