Please don’t be put off by the very few poor reviews on here, and listen to the good ones. Believe me. You don’t want to miss out on this hidden gem right here in New Berlin. My wife and I have eaten here on multiple separate occasions, and all of them have always exceeded our expectations! Chef Andrew and all of his staff do a phenomenal job to make this a very intimate, and pleasurable dining experience. My wife and I don’t go out to eat very often, but when we do, and want elegant dining and a meal that we know won’t disappoint, we can always count on this place. Our last visit was to celebrate my wife’s birthday. Our hostess Kathleen, was incredible! She was so nice, accommodating, and was very knowledgeable about the food, drinks, and everything else entailed. She helped make a great dinner even that much more enjoyable. Kudos to her! I was so appreciative to her for making my wife’s birthday a memorable evening, which is all that truly mattered to me. The food we had that evening was out of this world! Like previous experiences, our meals were cooked to perfection! Despite what the few, small negative reviews say, I can honestly say my wife and I have never had food prepared so amazing each of those times. The waygu steak I had (medium rare,) practically melted in my mouth. My wife had a venison entree that was also off the charts. The dessert I had too was so unbelievable! I highly recommend the citrus meringue pie if it’s on the menu. It was to die for! I have never had a meringue pie so delectable in my life! The meringue was so, so good! As a surprise to us both, they even presented a special dessert just for my wife’s birthday. She loved very bite. This restaurant goes above and beyond what any restaurant we have been to does. That’s what makes it our favorite, and our go to when we are celebrating any kind of special occasion. We know we are always going to leave happy. The prices for the quality and portions of the food you get are nothing short of amazing as well. You honestly can’t go wrong with this place. I’d bet you’d pay almost twice as much at other high end chain type restaurants, and you’ll miss out on the personal touch you get here. This is the only place I can say we’ve ever eaten at that is more of a dining “experience,” than just going out to eat. They do a great job timing the courses to keep the evening flowing, all while allowing ample time to savor what you’re enjoying. The only note as others have stated, is that the menu does change periodically, so be aware of that. Don’t worry though. I guarantee you will find numerous things at any given evening that you will find unbelievably appealing. I like that aspect, as it leaves a desire to come back and find out what other new delicacy chef Andrew will outdo himself with. He truly takes pride in the food he presents, and the atmosphere you dine in. He often makes rounds to meet guests, as well as make sure they have everything they need to enjoy their night. We will definitely be returning in the near future. Someday I’d like to stop for lunch. They have a waygu burger that I’ve heard from friends is outstanding. Thank you to everyone there for the continued incredible experiences! We look forward to the next time we can support this wonderful...
Read more
Learn more insights from Wanderboat AI.
