Pony Express Kitchen & Catering — Restaurant in New Lenox

Wow! Ordered the tailgate package for a Sunday Funday. Everything was incredible. Was ready on time, plentiful and delicious!!!.... Edit 10/23/23.... Loved it so much last week and so we ordered again this week! Tailgate package AND rotisserie chicken package for a family dinner. It was wonderful! These 2 meals served 15 (11 adults, 4 children) and still had leftovers! The only thing I wish I would have asked is if they could have broken the chickens down, so that we didn't have to fuss w/ that when we had company. I would gladly pay a...

Ordered smash burgers, Mac and cheese, pot roast tacos, fries and chips! Split it all up and tried it all between 7 adults and everybody loved it! Last taco devoured by the son in law later. He can’t wait to order and he’s right! They have some unique dishes that really work! We’ll be back! Still under construction but it’s a carry out and by the way….the folks were exceptionally friendly and that’s what makes...

Have ordered food there several times. Always pretty good. Had chicken parm sandwich yesterday and it was not good at all. Chicken was severely overcooked and truly inedible. I hope this is an isolated incident. I wish them well, but they need to hear the bad as well as the good. That's what makes a...