Papa GeGe's Italian Villa — Restaurant in New Middletown

I looked at their online menu for pricing. When I called the person on the phone repeated my order back wrong three times! When my husband picked up the order I told him to make sure it was correct. They charged him $30 for a pepperoni pizza that should’ve cost $24.99 according to their online menu on their own website. This was our first time ordering and we thought we would start out with pizza just to see how the service was and the food. We are very disappointed with the initial phone call to place our order and of course being overcharged six dollars did not help anything. We still did give the pizza a fair chance. We were sorely disappointed. The cheese was bland and didn’t have that tangy salty taste cheese should have on a pizza The pepperoni was cheap and there was oil all over the pizza. The next day the pepperoni did crisp up a bit more but was still bland. The sauce was okay. Overall, this was a bad experience and we will...

One of the best Italian restaurants by far! If you want authentic italian food! A little pricey but not bad, and definitely worth it. The portions are big as well! Love the...

Hope you are hungry. Large portions, delicious pizza, fantastic antipasto salad, sausage pepper roll is just...