Carmelas Pizzeria — Restaurant in Ohio

5 Stars for the pizza and staff! (Great job Carmela team) 1 lonely star for the management... keep reading.

First and foremost, the pizza is amazing! Hands down, no questions about it. If you crave NY style pizza, I can truly say this is your place. I've eaten pizza from around the world and I can say this pizza is on par with more than a few of them. With that said, the pizza rightly deserves 5 stars. Try it for yourself. Trust me - you will not be disappointed. The staff is also very friendly and helpful. Melissa, the waitress, is top notch.

However, Melissa, the manager, barely gets 1 star for this review. To give her the benefit of the doubt, maybe she was having a bad day. We all do and maybe this was her bad day. Either way, I must say, she did not treat me very kindly. I will also say she does not care for people taking pictures of the food.

I'll quickly explain. While I was waiting for my pizza, I decided to take a picture of a few fresh pizzas about to be served up to the local patrons. They looked so good I decided to take a picture and post it for everyone to see. To my surprise, Melissa (the manager) quickly came out of the back kitchen and demanded to know why I took a picture. I calmly explained that I wanted to post it on Google with my review. She rudely told me I should not be taking pictures of other peoples food. Even though I tried to explain that the picture was for a post, she continued to berate me in front of both staff and on-looking customers. Not cool at all.

I wish I could have shared more pictures Melissa (the...

I LOVE their Chicken Wings, which I get with bone in and unbreaded and with a mild sauce. I picked ore up Sunday before start of NFL season games. This is the BEST Sports Bar in Medway / New Carlisle area including all Clubs. Many TV's, Beer & Drinks / Great Food. Plus people were brining children in, a good Family Place. NOT a Biker Bar, which is way too common in this area. THE BEST SPORTS BAR RESTAURANT in this area. I would say like Slyders in Dayton but this is Better because more TV's. ...Now Me I would 86 the pictures on old farmers and put up more Sports stuff including Local Tecumseh School banners, but perhaps the old farmer pictures cut down on the Trouble Maker Crowd.....I would rather eat here than The Mel-O-Dee....To Me, this place is better than Moose, Eagles, VFW, AmVets, and any other bar or club to watch The Games. THE BEST Family Sports Bar Restaurant going. Most places have the Game on and Beer, but they don't have Food like this I like that they keep it a good FAMILY Place with no Trouble Makers that go to the other local dives around here. I can see this place keeps the Trouble Makers OUT, and The Family People are Their Customers. I LIKE THAT....Chicken Wings were good, even if my team lost....The Trouble Maker Places lose money and close, such as Chase Lounge and Pat & Marthas, because all the Biker type fights chase customers away. Carmela's is NOT like some of the dives this area known for. They run a nice tight ship and keep this a Nice Place To Go. This is like Buffalo Wings or TGIF,...

If I could give this place 10 stars, I would. From the moment I walked in, I knew I was in for something special. The aroma of freshly baked dough, bubbling cheese, and perfectly balanced toppings wafted through the air like an invitation to culinary heaven.

The crust was absolute perfection—crispy on the outside, airy and chewy on the inside. It had just the right amount of char, giving it that authentic wood-fired flavor. The sauce? A masterpiece. Tangy, slightly sweet, and seasoned to perfection. You can tell they use only the freshest tomatoes and herbs.

The toppings were where this pizza truly shined. They didn’t skimp on quality or quantity. Each ingredient—from the gooey mozzarella to the savory pepperoni and the delicate drizzle —was thoughtfully chosen and masterfully layered.

Service was top-notch too! The staff was friendly, attentive, and clearly passionate about their pizza. They even recommended the perfect craft beer to pair with my pie.

This isn’t just pizza—it’s an experience. Whether you’re a pizza purist or someone who loves creative, gourmet combinations, this place will blow your mind. I can’t wait...