Keystone Pizza — Restaurant in Payette

I've never given a five before. This place has the best food I've ever had. I'm not exaggerating. They make my favorite food I've ever had and they are the only place that can do it. Get the Pepperoni with extra Pepperoni. The Hawaiian is good too, but the Pepperoni is the best thing I've ever ate and I've tried food from all over the world. Stuff you could only dream of or read about online, for instance, I just had Durian today and White Sapote last week and Quail eggs tomorrow. I'm a food and beer aficionado.

I now live in Corvallis, Oregon. For 25.00 bucks they will make you a Gourmet pizza here in this rich little town, but nothing beats the dumpy little Keystone, in the middle of no where. The inside is falling apart, the staff isn't very nice (but they're not mean either) and the Pizza's are inconsistent, sometimes with enormous bubbles or they simply make it differently (extra or less pepperoni or too much sauce).

Assuming you want the best Pizza ever made, this is the place. If you can look over the short comings and try the place twice, you may see why I love this place so much. I grew up eating this Pizza since I could walk. I'm now 30. I have wonderful memories of this place...

The Pepperoni has a weird thing goin' on if you're lucky and that's what you want. If conditions are right, the Pepperoni gets crusty because it wasn't level with the dough and cheese, it gets crusty and that's what you want...because it distorts the flavor, kind of like how cheese that gets burnt when you make grilled cheese tastes different and good. That's why I suggest EXTRA Pepperoni.

I just got back into town from Idaho yesterday (four hundred miles away now) and I have a freezer stuffed with their Pizza's. I brought home a huge bag full. One time, during a rough finals week, I ordered a total of nine Pizza's from them, 14 inchers and I'm still not tired of them.

They need to bring back the video game Galaga...

Stay AWAY from Pizza bar, it's bad, always bad.

The Wednsday special is what I would suggest. 7.50 for a big Pizza.

I'm a good writer, I know I butchered the heck out of this...It's late and I'm sick with a fever so I don't...

Prices are pretty good if you go to the lunch buffet but there are a few visual elements that bring my rating down. First of all, I am aware that the atmosphere of the restaurant is supposed to be vintage looking, but I don't think they upkeep enough. They do need to remodel some parts. Now for the employees. 2 of the girls there are very friendly and professional. The rest dress like trailer trash. Spaghetti straps with cleavage hanging out, and an apron over it. Looks extremely trashy. They also wear jeans so tight when they bend over their muffin top hangs out. I believe they'd be alot better working at a bar. Food is pretty decent. Not the best but we love how quiet and kid friendly is there. Just a little too laid back there.

Update*

Looks like they've cleaned up alot, some new upgrades. They have pizza breadsticks that's why I keep coming back 💗👍 so far they dress more appropriate and can see the improvement. The girls there are always nice especially the same one we always see there. Thank you for improving...

Hello, I recently had an inquiry with the Payette, Idaho chain. We order two pizzas which were the specials which were supposed to equal out to 2 large two toppings for 23.99. We requested one Hawaiian pizza as well as one chicken bacon ranch pizza. The person who answered our call informed us that we would have to pay a $1.75 extra for our extra topping on our chicken bacon ranch pizza.

The delivery driver showed up to our house, and informed us that we owed $38.50. We had an issue with the price because of the total we were told over the phone. We questioned the driver whom deliver the pizza to our house about the issue and she informed us that it must have been the new hire whom took our order who may have messed it up.

We then declined our order and proceeded to call the chain that we had ordered from. We spoke to the manager whom apparent went by the name “Tyler” and got hung up on numerous times.

We were instructed to call back Friday morning to speak to another manager....

Throughly not impressed, highly would not...