Amici's Pizzeria — Restaurant in Plainfield

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Amici’s Pizzeria, and I must say, my experience was nothing short of extraordinary! Among the many delightful offerings on their menu, I was particularly excited to try their gluten-free cinnamon sticks, and I can confidently say they exceeded all my expectations.

From the moment I took my first bite, I was transported to a world of flavor. The cinnamon sticks had a wonderfully soft and pillowy texture that made them incredibly enjoyable to eat. They were perfectly baked, with just the right amount of crispness on the outside, creating a delightful contrast to the tender interior. The aroma of cinnamon wafted through the air, enchanting my senses and setting the stage for a truly indulgent treat.

The balance of sweetness and spice was impeccable. Each stick was generously coated with a rich cinnamon blend that offered a warm and inviting flavor profile, making them feel like a comforting hug in dessert form. To top it all off, the creamy icing drizzled on top added a luscious touch that complemented the cinnamon perfectly, enhancing the overall experience.

What truly impressed me was the fact that these delicious cinnamon sticks are gluten-free, making them an excellent option for those with dietary restrictions without sacrificing taste or quality. It’s a rare find to come across gluten-free desserts that are this delightful, and Amici’s has truly nailed it!

Moreover, the ambiance of the pizzeria was warm and welcoming, and the staff was incredibly friendly and attentive, ensuring that my dining experience was nothing short of fantastic. I left feeling satisfied and eager to return for more.

In conclusion, I wholeheartedly recommend Amici’s Pizzeria to anyone seeking delicious food, especially those in search of scrumptious gluten-free options. The gluten-free cinnamon sticks alone are worth the visit, and I can’t wait to indulge in them again. Five stars...

Disappointing.

First tried this newer place in early 2024, decided to get a little bit of everything to try it out. Cheese pizza - greasy, but delicious. I liked it but wife had digestive issues with the grease. Supreme pizza - little wet but ok. Buffalo wings - awesome, way better than what you get at any other chain pizza place. Breadsticks - ok. Mozzarella sticks - raw , uncooked, and cold. Pale white color, as is they only pulled them out of the freezer and toasted them for 60 seconds. Really bad.

Not being particularly impressed, we avoided this place for an entire year until they handed out coupons at the local Easter event in 2025, so we decided to give it another try. Wife really did not want to try it again but i begged her because i really liked the cheese pizza and wings from the first time. Well, guess who was right? It only got worse the second time unfortunately.

This time we ordered cheese pizza, bread sticks, and wings. Everything was cold when it arrived at our door, like sitting for 45min type of cold. I had a bad feeling when the delivery driver handed it to me and the cardboard box felt wet on the bottom. On top of being cold, the cheese pizza was a disaster. The dough was almost entirely raw. White color with raw doughy texture on the bottom and it just stuck to the box and fell apart when you tried to pull a piece out. It also had 2-3 times the amount of pizza sauce a pizza needs, was scraping most of it off which further caused the raw dough to come apart. The cheese itself still tasted ok but was cold. Breadsticks, cold, unremarkable. Wings, if they weren't cold, would still be the winner here. They actually have a solid hot wing.

Safe to say we'll probably never order from here again and stick to PPJs (wife's favorite, for me just so so) or try CJs or Greeks instead. Stinks because it's so close to our...

Initially we ordered the Breadsticks, and we were impressed by the crispy exterior and soft and pillowy interior. A good amount of seasoning, and the dipping sauces, cheese and marinara, were delicious. We thought, based on the Breadsticks, we were going to have amazing pizza. Sadly, the pizzas did not meet our expectations. We were dining in, and unsure why the pizzas were brought to the table in pizza boxes. Very strange because the pizzas could have been served on a pizza tray, and saved the boxes for take-out and deliveries. The dough on each of the pizzas was too thick, doughy, and couldn't find the crust. By the looks of the underside of the pizza it looks like it was baked on a plate which prevented the dough from being baked properly. The cheese pizza had a nice balance of red sauce and cheese. The Margarita pizza's base garlic sauce made the dough slimy, and the tomatoes should be cut smaller. Because of the large slices of tomatoes they kept sliding off the pizza. Either cut the tomatoes smaller or put them on top of the cheese, and use a red instead of garlic sauce. The Buffalo Chicken Pizza had far too much Ranch sauce, and made it unpleasant to eat. Next time put the Ranch sauce on the side, and add more Buffalo sauce on the chicken. The desserts we ordered were delicious, but unsure why they were brought to the table at separate times because we ordered them at the same time. The Brownie Pie was fudgy and so delectable. Then the Cinnamon Sticks were brought to our table, and had a wonderful scent of cinnamon. They tasted even better with the drizzle of powdered sugar. Not the pizza experience we...