Terryville Pizza — Restaurant in Plymouth

Little bit of a story time. My family ordered several pizzas from Terryville one night and one of the pizzas was margarita style with no cheese because of a dairy allergy. The pizza came with cheese on it even though we asked for no cheese. We called in to let them know and at first they were unsure if they had actually put cheese on it. They were busy so they just told us to bring it back in and they would take a look and replace it. The owner came over to me knowing that we were long time customers and apologized…he made it right with a new fresh pizza…AND he put extra toppings on the pizza and topped it off with a free dessert. Not only did he make it right for us but he now recognizes the order and makes sure that we get taken care of. These guys are amazing…and their dedication to their customers is the reason why we will only order pizza from this restaurant. Great people, great service, great food. I would give this pizza joint 100...

My family and I have been frequenting Terryville Pizza for over 6 years now. We absolutely love it! The owner and his wife are wonderful hard working people...their staff is great as well. They take great pride in their business. They care about their customers and only serve the best quality food. We have not ordered anything that we have not liked. My wife loves the eggplant parm. My daughter’s favorites are cheese pizza and the homemade chicken soup. My son enjoys the chicken parm and buffalo chicken wraps. As for myself, you can give me anything off the menu and I’ll be happy... I do have to say, the wings are the best I’ve ever had and I love their hot bread with butter! I give them a 5 star rating for...

Cleanliness, Service, Food Quality, and Value.

Looking forward to our next visit...

Try Terryville Pizza out for yourself, you will NOT be...

Very lucky indeed to have to do some chores this past June 2021 weekend in the neighborhood of one of our absolute favorite pizza parlors. It's been too long, so we had to order our usual: extra large sausage, pepperoni, meatball and green paper. Incredible, as always. The toppings are abundant and equally balanced, the sauce is lush and well seasoned, and the fresh crust is classically Greek style with a light but chewy bite and crisp finish. We agreed to try a couple of dinners next time for something new. Looking forward to it.

Updating this post, this is actually one of the best pizzas I've ever had and is in my top ten, and I've lived all over the place. Maybe even my top five. Perfect. Real nice owners, too. No alcoholic beverages on the premises. Casual main street building with booths and tables. Take out available.

Really...