Amico’s Pizza — Restaurant in Rutherford

We have visited twice now with our family (group of 7!) The pizza is a favorite among everyone!! Their wings are absolutely delicious and we have tried almost every flavor. The staff is so polite and friendly. It is a very small place, but they have a banquet/party room towards the back to accommodate a small gathering. It is hands down definitely our new favorite pizza shop and we will continue to support them. I promise my next trip I will remember to take photos of all...

Everybody here was really nice and the place was immaculate. I may have caught them after the lunch rush and I did just get slices. The Grandma Pizza was enjoyable and the sauce is great. The cheese slice had a generous portion of cheese and the sauce was tasty, but the crust wasn't sturdy enough to pick up the slice even using a NY fold. This is not my kind of crust. If you're a knife and fork pizza person, this may be to...

Top 3 worst pizza I've had in Swatara. Tried it for lunch today, got 2 slices to go, 1 plain 1 pepperoni. I'm 99% sure the pepperoni slice was leftover from yesterday. It looked like a reheated leftover, and absolutely tasted like a reheated leftover. I should've known.....the pepp slice was on a tray with a few slices of various other styles. They were probably all leftover from yesterday. ...