Pete’s Old Fashion Tomato Pies — Restaurant in Springfield Township

The South Jersey Legend! YES … it’s in a giant flea market YES … it’s only open Thu-Sun EDIT 2023:

I was in the area and stopped for lunch.

First the guy behind the counter yelled at the only customer waiting because the customer was on the “pickup” side instead of the “order” side.

Very “soup n@zi” vibes.

So after the guy took the order I requested a couple slices and a drink and the guy barked at me “card is $10 minimum “

Okay, no problem. But there’s no reason to be a jerk about it. I thought hefty guys were supposed to be jolly?

Maybe the pizza is still good but clearly the attention has gone to their head, I chose to get lunch elsewhere.

YES … it’s CASH ONLY YES … it’s in the middle of NOWHERE YES … it’s a legit TOMATO PIE YES … it’s awesome!

Does it have the pillowy goodness of L&B, or the 3D magic of Mancini Pizza? No. But it’s...

Hats off to Pete's Pizza! I started off as a Pete's Pizza customer then they changed their recipe and it was awful and we recently went back for a slice while waiting for our Kate and Al's pie order to be ready and WOW! The pizza FINALLY tastes like the original Pete's Pizza we fell in love with! The pizza at Kate and Al's was so awful (bitter sauce/bread too thick and soggy) that we ended up throwing away the entire pie we ordered. After the first bite of Pete's it kept us wanting more of the slice we just devoured. And kudos to finally accepting credit cards! Please, please do not change your recipe again as you have finally achieved perfection in a pizza....

The one in Columbus farmers market is a joke. Well the cashier that works there is at least. The pizza did look amazing. I paid for my pizza and waited 15 minutes and, waited still. I watched customers walk up and, place orders after me and, get there slices first. I was standing in front, right up at the bar. The guy that took my order and, money skipped over me three times. Needless to say I never received any pizza. I was tired of, being ignored and, skipped over so I started to walk away. That is when the cashier finally wanted to...