DiCarlo's Pizza - Downtown Steubenville — Restaurant in Steubenville

We ordered 12 slices with pepperoni and extra cheese. The pizza comes with pepperoni automatically. You have to tell them no pepperoni if you don't want it on your pizza. The locals know this so if you're from out of town that's something you should know. That being said, our pizza was PERFECT! The crust was just the right amount of crispness, the sauce was delicious (not to sweet or salty), and the extra cheese was plentiful! There are several pizza shops in the area to choose from. You can't go wrong choosing the downtown location. We'll...

Best $5 bucks spent on pizza EVER!! Amazing bargain! I know you're wondering why the cheese isn't melted, but you'll have to trust the pizza magic that is the lightest, crispiest crust you'll ever enjoy! The sauce is bright, and the cheese has a mellow yet flavorful impact on the square slices... in a side note, we had superb service! Our counter employee went above and beyond!! (Our 4 slices were so delicious we ordered a sheet to take home!!!) We're two hours away, but we'll make excuses to come back for...

Called before 5pm... spoke to girl, gave order and clarified several times. told 20- 25 min. Arrived at 20 min.. not ready ..had to state again order. 10 min later same girl tried to just give part of order. She had nerve to ask me, "did you call Sunset?" Waited a few more mins, then told another 10 min wait for my remain order.. Told them I'm leaving .. its ashame orders cant be taken correctly...esp. when it's from a REGULAR CUSTOMER...FOOD GOOD, BUT GUESS WE WONT HAVE...