Thirsty Turtle — Restaurant in Stoddard

Super disappointed!

I have been raving about the Steak Sandwich at the Thirsty Turtle for the past year, which is the last time we were there.

Finally visited again last night. At our table alone, five Steak Sandwiches were ordered.

Every one was awful. My first bite literally was all gristle, and the rest of the sandwich wasn't much better. Half of my sandwich was inedible, and was left on the plate.

The other four sandwiches at the table weren't much better. I was embarrassed to have suggested it to our other guests.

Service was non-existent. There was no way to complain about the sandwich because the waitress never showed up at our table again. It took us 15 minutes to pay at the bar and just get the hell out of there.

No longer a go-to restaurant for me. I...

A must stop if you are in the area! We had the best Chicken Cordon Bleu sandwich and Blue Balls appetizer (make sure to dip these in their signature sauce) made by their cook Mary, who clearly has the passion for what she does! “Made with love” is what she said and you need see it for yourself. Amazing service at their friendly bartender, Jessie. We came for a quick meal and drink and we ended up leaving with our bellies and heart full. We came in as strangers and left as friends. Thank you Mary and Jessie! We...

A group of 6 of us Stopped for a few drinks about lunch time. They were about 6 other patrons in the bar eating or finishing up eating. There were 2 bartenders and neither seemed like they had time for us. Going about their own discussions and had little time for us. After other left we moved from the side of the bar to up to the bar. They didn’t take the time to wiped up here others left the lunch mess. Asked to do the daily shake of days and that seems to...