Main Street Restaurant — Restaurant in Town of Arcadia

05/18/2023: Best restaurant in town by far. Never a bad meal. The owner Tom always greets us (when he's not washing dishes). Hard-working, conscientious, great service and atmosphere -- and a CHEF, not a cook!

UPDATED 08/15/2023: Main Street remains the best place in town BY FAR. Other Newark restaurants have decent food, no question, but the last meal I was served at Main St. was the best of it's kind I've EVER had. My son is a chef and I know the difference. Main St. provides top-shelf entrees, superbly prepared, fast friendly service in a clean, comfortable, warm, welcoming environment. Does it get any better? They're the clear winner -- they've earned it.

UPDATED 05/12/2024: I just consumed as much as I could of the best roast beef club, onion rings and French onion soup I've ever had in my life, with a huge box to take home. I'll probably get three scrumptious meals out of this. The owner stopped by my table to chat and make certain everything was...

Went in at 5, didn’t walk out until 7. Menu is pretty much the same, but with even less options as the last two establishments that were in that location prior. My appetizer was good, husbands was frozen out of box. Order came, my entree was swimming in a sauce, which should not have been saturated as such. My husbands order was incorrect, therefore we had to wait another 10-15 for his pasta to be corrected. By that time, I was finished eating. He had a pasta only dish that ended up costing more than my dish which contained chicken that was really rubbery. I noticed the fish fries and am really glad that I did not order one as they did not look appetizing at all and looked really dried out. I keep hoping that someone will go in to that location and really turn it around. Something different, something with more variety and appeal. Unfortunately that never happens. We will not...

I will give this place another try this year and update my review accordingly.

We were here for about 90 minutes. The food took about 45-60 minutes I believe our appitizer was given to another table creating the delay. Our initial plates had crums on them so we asked for new ones. The calamari was terrible and they hardly added any to the plate so we sent them back and they removed it from our bill. We also tried the chicken tender appitizer but they were just normal frozen tenders reheated nothing special and the fries you could tell were fried with old oil as they were very hard and burnt. The fried haddock sandwich was decent and so was the vodka sauce pasta with chicken. The place was very cold making me put my coat back on to stay warm. My girlfriend had a good experience here last time so per my initial statement I will have to give them another chance in the future and...