Brother's Trattoria — Restaurant in Town of Beekman

We bought our forever home in 2022, and have just found our favorite neighbor. 1.5 miles literally, lol. The hot and spicy shrimp and spicy calamari appetizers were delicious. The sauce with the shrimp had so much flavor and it was a nice thick tomato consistency to eat with the toasted bread. The calamari was cooked perfect with a beautiful thick sauce, beautiful spice that sticks with your taste buds. We also ordered a meatball Parm. It was excellent. The flavors of all the ingredients in the meatballs complimenting each other. No notion of over bread crumbing them to the point of that compounded taste. Absolutely delectable. The calamari fra diablo had a smooth thick sauce that was sweet with the hints of fresh garlic and fresh basil. Simply amazing. Hands down flavors that make them distinctly on another level than most places. There pizza is also great, however NO, this is not a pizza place. Prices are fair, and the quality of cuisine is worth it!! We will see you soon...

My FIRST and ONLY time going to this place! I ordered my for my first time from this place on the slice app. I paid prior to going to pick up. I paid 1$ each for a total of 4$ for 4 toppings on my $18 pizza. I paid $28 total for 1 ONE pie,, with a tip.. When I got there they told me that I was charged incorrectly and I needed to pay 2.50 a topping. I told them I ordered based on what it charged me online and I'm not paying OVER 30$ for ONE pizza. I called the slice app and they offered to cover the difference on my order. When the slice app representative called this place TO TELL THEM TO COMPLETE THE ORDER they hung up on him! How Rude! Not a nice way to treat customers. Too bad because it's located 2 minutes from my house. Now they have a pizza sitting there freshly made at 7 pm and it's going to end up in the trash anyway. He said he's not giving anything away for free. Glad I...

Horrible... I have never felt so uncomfortable. I had gone in with my friends and we had a gift certificate for a large pizza and then we were seated... which was fine . We were not dressed like everyone else since we had just played a charity softball tournament benefiting Multiple Sclerosis Society .... so after we were seated and they found out we had a gift certificate we were told they won't serve pizza to us in the dining room on a Friday or Saturday night.... Then we're told there were people waiting so we gave up our table. Then walking out to waiting area - there was NO ONE waiting ... I have never felt so discriminated against .... and unwelcome in my life. I will never return and waste my money to a place that is so...