Capio's Pizzeria & Restaurant — Restaurant in Town of Brookhaven

I ordered a margherita pizza (the one with tomatoes and cheese; I don't remember the exact name). It came out in a sopping mess. They gave me a box for the pizza and it quickly became clear that the water would go through that box (it was very thin). I had to ask for a second box (which was the same size so did not contain the first box). The staff did not react to this situation at all for some reason (implying this is normal for them), but did give me the second box. The pizza itself was like eating watery dough and tomatoes. Literally the worst pizza I've ever had! The place seemed clean and friendly, though. I never went back. (This was sometime in the beginning of last year). It is baffling to me that they have such good reviews, but perhaps this experience was not representative of the whole. It's simply a chance I'm not willing to...

Considering it was lent I ordered from this Pizzeria a shrimp Parmesan dinner when it arrived at my house and had taken it in as I opened it, it looked like chicken cutlets to me even the delivery driver said I made these chicken cutlets just for you. I knew I couldn't try it so I have one of my friends who was not Catholic to try it and they definitely said it was shrimp once I tried it OMG the shrimp was phenomenal this was the best shrimp Parmesan dinner I ever had thank you so much. September 5th and 6th 2025 we had ordered from this place for two nights in a row I am testing out all their food the food is outrageous this is excellent food so we decided we're going to get the menu and we're going to pick out dinner for the next week so we don't have to cook thank you guys your...

There okay but we asked for plates and cups many times many times forgotten but this last time the girl straight up lied and said we didnt ask and then told me three dollars and then my cousin five dollars to litterally drive down the road to fix there mistake like oh my word and she was rude about it but she lied instead of saying "i apologize its my mistake" nope she straight up LIES IN OUR EARS AND WE HAD WITNESSES PSHT NEVER AGAIN THERES BETTER PLACES TO ORDER FROM ANYWAY WHAT IF WE JUST MOVED IN HERE WE HAD SO MANY KIDS HERE AND NOT ENOUGH PLATES OR CUPS TO GO AROUND WE HAD TO ROTATE AND USE BOWLS AND WE DIDNT HAVE THE THREE OR FIVE DOLLARS THAT SHE WANTED TO DRIVE DOWN THE BLOCK BECAUSE SHE FORGOT. OVERRATED PIZZA ANYWAY PROBABLY NOT EVEN ITALIANS COOKING IT.......