Forage and Gather Market & Cafe — Restaurant in Town of Fallsburg

Forage and Gather Market & Café is a gem of a place, perfect for a quick coffee, a meal, or even a relaxing sit-down with friends. Their coffee is top-notch, with a rich taste that speaks to the quality of their beans and the care they put into brewing. The espresso machine seems to be well-maintained and clean, which definitely adds to the flavor.

The sandwiches are another highlight. With their “build your own” option, you can get creative, and the quality of the ingredients is outstanding—most of which appear to come from local vendors. This attention to sourcing adds to the appeal of the place. The pastries are equally impressive. They seem to be made in-house, as I haven’t come across similar options anywhere else. They’re fresh, delicious, and worth trying.

The café itself is cozy, with plenty of seating and a super friendly staff that makes you feel welcome. It’s a great spot to relax or work for a while. However, one suggestion I’d make is to improve the ventilation in the cooking area. While it’s not a major issue, enhancing it could make the ambiance even better.

It’s clear that the place has undergone changes recently—whether it’s a new opening or an ownership change—but the results are fantastic. Forage and Gather has really stepped up its game, and I’m excited to see how it continues to evolve.

I wholeheartedly recommend this spot for anything from a quick bite or to-go coffee to a full sit-down experience, even including alcoholic beverages. Kudos to the team running the...

This is a cute little shop. It has a small store in the front with what looks like a lot of organic products. Got an egg and cheese sandwich and flavored latte. They only have whole milk, coconut milk, or almond milk which was slightly disappointing, but the drink was really good, the barista even had a swirl in latte art on the top even though it was to go. The egg and cheese sandwich is made to order with fresh eggs. It was really delicious. Friendly staff and a very welcoming atmosphere, a little on the pricy side. When I went in today there was even a little waffle pop up stand in there too which...

I've been coming to Hurleyville for nearly 50 years (my family has been here over a century), and never did I think I'd be able to get a good matcha latte in town. What a sweet spot to buy something special and hang out for a bit. And they go above and beyond. I was just in town for a family reunion. I had made pesto for 25 people and then left it at home (5 hours away). We called to find out they sell vegan pesto, and they put it aside some for me, suggesting that I could add cheese from La Salumina down the road if I wanted. I did. It was excellent. I look forward to coming back next time...