Mr. Crispy's Brick Oven Pizza — Restaurant in Town of Haverstraw

Took an hour ride from East Rutherford, NJ to try out Mr. Cristy’s Pizza/Restaurant. The Pizza was absolutely fantastic. Penne Vodka was out of this world and the Shrimp Alfredo over pasta my wife absolutely loved.

They also have these deep fried garlic knocks which were our first time having, also were great. The service was very very good and the owner Chris comes out to check on you to make sure you are happy. I highly recommend this restaurant.. Would give it 20 STARS ...

Prices have gone way up since change of hands. Phone service for takeout and delivery is bad, they don’t listen. The order is never right. When you call back and let them know and ask the owner to call you, they don’t. Try anywhere but here. Pizza in Rockland is bad but this place is a joke.

Update as of 9/15/25 it is now $38 for a large pizza with one topping and a 2 litter to be delivered. That is absurd, especially when it’s never...

The pizza was good from this place in the past. Tonight I picked up 2 pies for $58. A Sicilian Pepperoni & a Buffalo chicken pizza that appeared too large to fit in the box. So what do you do when the pizza is too large, you fold it so it fits. I called to let them know that I was not happy with the condition of the pizza. All they could offer is an apology. Never again will they see a $$ of my money. Both pizzas...