Catusco's Pizza — Restaurant in Town of Huntington

One of the best slices of pizza on Long Island!

In less than a week, I returned with a friend to eat here for lunch. We started with slices, (2) Hot Honey Vodka Square with Pepperoni, and we split (1) Chicago-style with Pepperoni and Sausage. While we ate those, we patiently waited for our kitchen orders. Shrimp Parmigiana Hero with Vodka sauce and an order of (8) parm garlic wings. The hero was fantastic. Bread was crisp, and that vodka sauce is super flavorful. The wings came out super hot, and they were really flavorful. It was like, Garlic Knot wings, tbh, so it was surprisingly delicious alone, without any ranch/blue cheese. As if we didn't order enough, the owner graciously surprised us with a complimentary stromboli.

A+ customer service, prices are more than reasonable, and the food is 10/10. ANYTHING with their vodka sauce is a knockout, and that Hot Honey Vodka Square with Pepperoni is in our top 3 slices on LI, possibly in all of NY. There's a good reason why this pizza place is so highly rated.

--Previous Review Below--

Lived in NY my whole life, lived on LI since '93. LI has delicious pizza. Ever since I've moved to Huntington, I'd get pizza from the usual spots. But then I had Catusco's... Let me preface this review- What got me into the door was the Too Good Too Go app. No regrets at all, because each time I was able to sample some of their specialty slices. Even their plain and their Sicilian are EXCELLENT. I couldn't believe it, they really deserve the high reviews. I know what your'e thinking, there are hundreds of pizza places on Long Island, but if you're in the Huntington area, for your next lunch, your next dinner, don't hesitate to get a pie from them.

Some star items are, the Marsala, Hot Honey Vodka Square with Pep or Sausage, and even their Spinach Artichoke slice that rivals Artichoke in the city, and Sausage and Pepper Roll! (There were a few more I had, but I forgot to take a pic since I...

Best Pizza In Town!

Had the opportunity to find Catusco’s a week after moving into the area. Before I even reached the counter I was greeted by James and his staff. They made me feel like I was right at home from my first encounter before I even had an opportunity to order.

Let’s get down to the pizza…. AMAZING doesn’t begin to describe it. James uses a mix of creative ideas and grade A ingredients to constantly supply a mix of amazing slices daily. Each time I walk in I make sure to try a different slice and I never walk out disappointed.

With what seems like a Michelin Star Chef in the back, Catusco’s is not just limited to pizza. My wife and I enjoy the plethora of options James provides.

I highly recommend anyone is the area stop by and try a slice. I promise you won’t be...

This is where we go for pizza. It is close. It is good. Better than good! The cauliflower crust is particularly good for you gluten free guys. Last night they really came through for us. I had ordered wings delivered from a local specialty place- Toxic Wings. At 5 minutes before the scheduled and confirmed delivery time I received a cancellation notice. Sorry for the inconvenience! Hungry teenagers are not just an inconvenience as they circle the crudites with horror.

I called Catusco's and they came through with 6 orders of the best wings I have ever tasted! In 25 minutes! The garlic-parmesan is amazing. Even with the rush order they were perfectly cooked and sauced. Thai...