Timothy's Pizza Kitchen — Restaurant in Town of Huntington

This is a small pizzeria very humble and with very little fanfare. However the pizza itself is excellent with excellent quality ingredients. New to the area and living very close by my wife and I were extremely hopeful that Timothy‘s would be good. We were pleased and I guess you could say relieved that the pizza is indeed excellent. The owner and operator Michael is so hard-working so genuinely kind, a humble guy that you can’t help but root for an establishment like this. There are many other pizzerias in the area and we’ve tried them all some of them a little bit more modern than Timothy‘s is. Yet time and time again my family tries out the pizzerias and says Timothy is still better. Facts: They deliver locally. There is easy parking in the parking lot off the street right outside of the pizzeria. We especially love the garlic knots I always order a batch even if I have them the next day with a...

Stopped in while in the area. The pizza was honestly worse than what you'd get from a school cafeteria. It's better off that you just drive to the city, because the cheap dollar slices there are still far better than this was.

The employee also apparently thinks a face mask is meant to solely cover his mouth and not his nose.

If you see the sign, keep on moving and...

This is hands down the best NY style pizza I’ve ever had…and I’ve had a lot. The sauce, the cheese, and oh my, the crust! And it’s been this good for years. I discovered it more than 15 years ago when my daughter was taking piano lessons nearby. It’s still so delicious that we drive all the way from Babylon whenever a...