Vitos Pizzeria & Restaurant — Restaurant in Town of Huntington

Well, let's just say we're still on the quest for the best pizza in the area.  We ordered a sicilian pie with sausage and 1 slice of the famous buffalo chicken pizza, just to taste it.  We asked for the sicilian well done, not burnt, and it still came underdone, and not hot.  We heated it up in the oven at home which helped a bit, but it was lackluster and the sauce was too sweet for us.  There was a meager amount of sausage on it and the sausage was sliced, not crumbled, which is not our preference. The buffalo chicken slice was quite good - very saucy/messy and filling but good flavor and not too spicy.  My husband and I are divided on the crust - I thought it held up nicely to support the toppings, but he felt it was too bready. Would be 1 star review from us, but will give it 2 stars because we liked the buffalo chicken slice.

Editing the review to say that the owner “made good” on our first order. The replacement pizza was better, still not well done enough (they said well done is burnt?). Had to put it in the oven. Crumbled sausage much better than sliced. Adding a star for...

The second i stepped into Vito's Pizzeria I was immediately greeted by a warm, inviting atmosphere that promises a memorable dining experience. The service is prompt, friendly, and attentive, making you feel right at home from the moment you arrive. But the true star of the show is the food. Each pizza is a work of art, with a perfectly crispy crust, rich, flavorful sauce, and fresh toppings that will have you savoring every last bite. Whether you're a regular or a first-timer, Vito's Pizzeria delivers on its promise of excellent food, top-notch service, and a...

Ordered a whole pie with pepperoni .. Received half pepperoni… Spoke with Vito himself and he took my name and number to offer to “fix it” with a complimentary pie. Went in person for pickup and the ppl looked at me like im the crazy person. It was beyond embarrassing. You mess up the first time ok, let it go but two times??? Theres plenty of pizza stores that can have my business. Thats just disrespectful to keep giving me half pepperoni when the RECEIPT and when I called I mentioned WHOLE PEPPERONI multiple times. For a new pizzeria, I...