Pizza Shack of Kismet — Restaurant in Town of Islip

Expensive for lg cheese pie $25. Garlic knots were not good, pizza ok. Teen girls serving behind counter need customer service skills. When asked about a menu they just pointed and turned around. Sign was on side of bldg. Asked for waffle cone but no eye contact and gave reg cone..not going to waste it so I paid for it..again expensive but that's expected on an island. Can only sit on picnic tables which were sticky. Its convenient and nice to sit outside...

Pizza was very mediocre, esp for the price. I ordered green pepper topping, and it was literally like 6 thin slices of raw bell pepper dropped on a reheated slice. What didn’t help was seeing how the worker who prepared mine didn’t wear gloves as they grabbed a handful from the tupperware of sliced bell pepper. I’ve had way better tasting pizza for...

You need a slice before your trip back? You want an ice cream cone? You want to feel like you just ended your visit to kismet on the highest note possible? Then the pizza shack is your new favorite place.

Grab some comfort and leave Kismet with a smile, or stay!!! Just know that the pizza shack had you...