Main St. Cafe — Restaurant in Town of Mendon

After a hike at Mendon Ponds, we were ready for lunch. My friend ordered first and chose the tuna wrap from the specials board. I ordered The Martin Sandwich on gluten free bread. After I ordered, the server advised they were out of the tuna wrap. So, my friend says he'll take the chicken salad on wrap. Nope, out of that too. So friend ordered the same as me only on a Wrap. We didn't have to wait very long and our food was ready. We chose to sit outside which is great to have on such a pretty day. But for $35 including tip for two sandwiches and a medium lemonade, I expected better. The gluten free bread was awful... stale and dry. I know there are better gf choices, and don't understand why the quality never seems to matter to places who offer it. The sandwich was supposed to have avocado and I think between the two of us, we had maybe a tablespoon of it. And the condiments were only on one slice, leaving the other side dry and tasteless. The side of chips appeared to be an afterthought, and apparently the bottom of the bag, as they were all crushed into small pieces. It's nice to have a place in Honeoye Falls, but Main Street Cafe needs...

I really wanted to love this cafe, but my experience was less than desirable. Rounding up my 3.5 out of 5 starts to 4 because I'd still like to come back and try other items on their menu. I ordered a medium latte, but it wasn't as strong as it typically is. It tasted like steamed milk with a little bit of espresso(like a watered down version of a latte, but with milk). I got the avocado toast and my eggs were over hard and I kept getting chunks of eggshells and after the 4th bite with crunchy eggshells, I lost my appetite and stopped eating it all together.

While I appreciate the amount of avocado toast I got, I would have liked it more had it been prepared better. Their menu was quite extensive for being a small cafe so I hope my next visit will be a better experience. Over all, I'm happy to support a local shop and my honest feedback will promote some consistency...

I ordered a milkshake online around 6 PM. Showed up to pick it up 20 minutes later, but it wasn’t made yet. When I arrived, I walked around for a bit then finally had to say “hello” in a loud voice to get one of the employees attention. One was wiping down counters and another was texting on his phone. Meanwhile, a young couple was getting their milkshakes and walking out the door. Maybe they ordered online ahead of me, but I then waited another 10 minutes to actually get the milkshake, with no apologies for the delay. I can’t imagine how long it would’ve taken if I had ordered food. And why bother to order online if they are taking walk in orders in front of online orders. Probably won’t go back, not...