The Crazy Bagel — Restaurant in Town of Oyster Bay

love this place, been buying the broadway sandwich for years and usually always see the same guy who i assume is the owner or manager but haven’t seen him lately. came in earlier in the month and got my usual order but this time the muenster cheese was rancid and my bagel had the thinnest layer of cream cheese i’ve ever seen. i know things happen in the food industry and workers aren’t gonna go around smelling cheeses to make sure they’re still good but i couldn’t eat that sandwich. love this place otherwise, so im just gonna assume that things can get messy when the owner isn’t around. they did offer to make another sandwich for me but i didn’t have the time to drive back so i thank them for that! other than that one incident this place is great, and i ordered the sandwich again and it was fine as usual so dont let my experience steer you away. this message is mainly for the owner so he can better train the newer employees and keep...

update: i gave this bagel place another shot. bad choice- still a disappointment. I am currently pregnant and specified i needed well done bacon on an egg sandwich . They don’t listen to what the customer wants they do what they want. I provided a photo of my “well done bacon”. Gross.

Owner likes to put you on hold for 20 minutes until you get fed up and hang up. Big disappointment- I wanted to make a large order up for catering. They just lost a longtime customer since this place...

Quick store front bagel shop. Had a wrap with eggs, swiss & spinach, as well as a buttered bagel. Coffee is self service. Got my black coffee and waited for the wrap & bagel - 3 min max. I was worried about how good the wrap was going to be given how quickly it got made - but hey, it was delicious. The bagel was also very good. I took it out to my car. Three out of the four tables were taken - a little too crowded for this big girl. Surprisingly large menu for a...