Goodfellas Pizzeria & Restaurant — Restaurant in Town of Poughkeepsie

Stopped in yesterday for a pie, visiting from out of town. Grew up around here. My family has ordered pies here since I was a kid. This is hands down the best pizza in Poughkeepsie, and possible even the state. The only real competition was DDs and they closed down. It's made fresh to order 100% of the time, just call in 15 minutes ahead of time. Don't know how they do it but the bread is mouth-watering and the cheese/sauce is just perfect. I love this place. My wife grew in in NYC so she knows pizza. She had a slice yesterday and she thought it was out of this world. I love this place, I hope they never change. I don't understand where all the negative reviews came from. They seem bogus to me. I've lived all over the eastern seaboard and must have tried 100 pizza joints, and nothing even...

I cannot support a business that would sneak in hidden fees as well as upcharge their own product. Order the week prior. Got an XL pie and soda. Didn't pay until I arrived. Had one person check out in front of me. As soon as they closed out their tab he immediately added a 1.50 charge on top of that the pizza was priced higher than their menu and a high cost for soda but that's expected at a restaurant. Certain restaurants have decided they're able to impose a take out (in)convenience fee and truthfully I won't support that. In most cases all anyone can do is get take out right now. At the very least if you're going to impose an added cost be upfront about it. But you've lost...

Moved to the area 2 years ago. Bounced around pizzerias trying to see what's what... Found myself going back to Goodfellas time again. They have a wide menu for a pizzeria restaurant, pizza quality/size is great, diner dishes are splendid. If you have allergies, you just need to clearly communicate and they will help as much as possible. Dinning in is separate/offset from the pizza counter which is nice. They do charge $1 or so for card charge which is expected.

Long story short - best pizzeria in the spackenkill...