Two Brothers Pizza 2 — Restaurant in Town of Rhinebeck

I have eaten at Two Brothers Pizzeria in Rhinebeck, N.Y. numerous times, and my experiences have been so good that I felt it was time to write a review. The items I had (pizza, sandwiches, and salads) have all been excellent, made with fresh ingredients, with excellent preparation, and presentation. No limp lettuce and items that look like they've been thrown on your plate here. The owner and his staff are friendly, attentive, and treat you like they appreciate your business. The restaurant is pleasant and clean (including the restrooms). I also like that they give a shout-out to our troops on the menu. I plan on returning many times to try other offerings.

I've been back many times since my initial review, and must say that this restaurant continues to impress me. The ingredients, preparation, and level of service all remain excellent. The owner (Scott) is usually behind the counter, and always expresses his appreciation for your business, both in words and in the quality of the food he serves you. He recently freshened up the restaurant with new paint and lighting. I really didn't see anything wrong with the way it was, but he is an owner that takes pride in his business, and wants to keep it nice for his customers. Great food, great service, fair prices. Stop by. You won't be...

I genuinely love the food from here and it’s a go to for me and my friends often. Me and others absolutely love the rice balls that they have but it’s has seemed that we have to make sure we call ahead and hope that the owner is in. Every other time we have gone in and there are none in the display case they “don’t have them” but when the owner is in they have “whatever and however much we would like”. Which I have no problem if they are frozen they are still good. I do not live in the area so when I’m around I would like to get them. It’s just the point of going into the back to get them I do not mind waiting but it’s is...

Ordered a plain hamburger and a California burger. When I get there they gave me a cheeseburger. They said they would remake it and I said just refund for the cheeseburger so my wife’s order wouldn’t get cold. The owner pops out and ensures they will remake both. After 5 minutes my food emerges. When I get home I realize they just peeled the cheese off not even all the way. And left some veggies in my container. And it was cold. I’m not a fool you didn’t remake it. Disrespectful to your customers. You are the ones who messed up the order. Never eat here. Also extremely overpriced food that...