FOLEYS Smithtown — Restaurant in Town of Smithtown

I can't, for the life of me fathom how this place managed to amass a 4.8 score. I definitely just had one of the worst experiences in a establishment that serves food ever.

There was one person who was waiting and serving drinks, she look like she was maybe 13 years old, did not know how to make a lot of the drinks, and the food we received was some of the worst Food I've ever ordered from an establishment (we ordered burgers, and the loaded bacon ranch fries which was suggested as well as half a dozen wings). There is no way the burgers are grilled, they were dry and overcooked. The fries were soggy and incredibly greasy. It tasted like everything is air fried. I wouldn't recommend this play to anyone not even if a person was dying from starvation and landed right in front of the bar. We ordered fries that have bacon on it and the bacon was pretty much raw, all the food came out staggered. We ordered three different dishes and everything came out at separate times.

There was cartoons playing at the bar, no music, and someone wanted to play the lottery since they have a machine there but the person couldn't play since the bartender did not know how to operate the lotto machine. I was there with a buddy as we had just visited a local pop culture convention in the area and was absolutely astonished at what we encountered seeing that this place had a 4.8 rating. They must be paying the local drunks that were all there to get such a score. I suggest saving your time and money and avoiding this place unless you want just a bottle of beer which is...

Recently held an 80 person surprise 50th birthday party at Foleys and wanted to express my gratitude to the owners and share our experience.

The owner Stacey was beyond accommodating to all of my changes, calls and requests throughout the weeks before the party. (Never once did she make me feel I was driving her insane which I probably knew I was 😂) Regardless of my amount of people, she kindly offered to shut the entire bar down for us from 5-8 so we had it all to ourselves. I was worried about the party leaving at exactly 8pm so she ended up surprising us by moving up her late night DJ to 8:30 to help prevent that. Because of that our guests stayed way past 8 and we had a great night. We used their in house caterer for food which she helped set up throughout the night and she even allowed me to arrive super early to set up all my decorations. The in house caterer was a nice perk because she helped give recommendations on amounts and which items to choose- plus there was no confusion on where food went and how to set it up. All I did was place my order and the delivery and setup was all communicated through the caterer and bar. We were able to play our own music, she helped me set up a slideshow on her big screen, our party got to play pool and darts (they have 3 dartboards), we got bring in our own dessert, etc etc- The whole party was everything we could have asked for. Thank you again to Stacey, Tom and the entire Foleys team for a truly...

I’m not usually one to leave reviews, but my experience at Foley’s made me feel the need to. After seeing great reviews about their burger online, I decided to place an order for pickup. I ordered a burger, fries, and wings and was told it would be ready in 30-40 minutes.

I arrived right on time—about 35-40 minutes later—and there was one person eating at the bar, along with the bartender who had taken my order over the phone. When I let her know I was there for pickup, she responded with, “Well, that’s awkwardddd.” I was completely confused. Then, the man eating at the bar casually said, “I think I ate your burger.” At first, I thought he was joking, but then the bartender admitted, “I’ll be real honest, it’s gonna be another 15-20 minutes to cook up a new one,” with zero remorse or apology.

At that point, I told her to cancel the entire order—I didn’t want any of it. She didn’t flinch, didn’t apologize, and just said, “Alright.” I haven’t experienced that level of unprofessionalism and poor customer service in a long time. Needless to say, I won’t be back.

I took my business to Jack Dolan’s Irish Pub right down the block instead, and...