Fatman's Pizza — Restaurant in Town of Tonawanda

HANDS DOWN the absolute very BEST pizza on the PLANET!!!

Buried in the Buffalo snow? Healing a broken heart? Want a break from the endless tire of working away behind the stove for a few days? Do you want to have a baby without actually having a baby?

¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?

Order a meatlover tray from Fatman's Pizza.

Lived in Chicago for 3 years and had all the deep dish my heart wanted or could physically handle. Also lived near Toronto, D.C., and been to Italy... there is no better, fully loaded, belly stuffing, and craving satisfying meat lover pizza than a FULL TRAY MEATLOVER pizza from Fatman's.

Tips on sauce/topping choices: The women (and men) in my life "love love love" Fatman's sweet marinara sauce, and I'd be letting you down if I didn't also say that their standard tomato marinara is one of the best marinara sauces around. Don't order extra sauce or toppings... it's called Fatman's pizza for a reason! I am not exaggerating when I say that a full tray weighs more than my 3.5 year old boy...

Just do yourself a favor and indulge. Give your tummy one of the greatest gifts that you can give it, and do not look back (definitely do not look at the scale).

You'll thank me for this review, later. You're welcome, I'm just a vessel in God's...

This is my first time trying this place. I ordered 1/2 tray half cheese ,half cheese/pepperoni and 30 wings 1/2 honey bbq and 1/2 garlic parm. My first impression, not overly impressed since half the pizza was burnt. I do like the overall taste of the dough ( although a little dry because it was over cooked), the crust had a nice crunch too it though. The cheese has a nice flavor and not too salty like some places can be. The sauce is a sweet sauce, which I liked alot ( I really only like sweeter sauces). Also the pepperoni's were very nice ,small cup n char but not too thick cut. Overall very good pizza, even though it was burnt. I would definitely try them again. I didn't bother to try to call to notify them that it was burnt. I'm sure they would have replaced it. We were hungry and just wanted to eat, plus it's like 15 minutes from my house. The chicken wings were pretty good and cooked crispy like I asked. The honey bbq was very good, it had a different flavor to it that I have never had before. The garlic Parm had a nice flavor to them. However with some of the wings, the sections were not sperated at all. Also my wife says the blue cheese was the best...

We ordered a large pepperoni pizza and traditional wings with mild sauce. The guy that took the order was really helpful and polite. So far, so good. Told us 45-60 minutes and it was here in 50. Good estimate and driver gets good tip.

However, I didn’t notice but the wing sauce leaked out everywhere because they simply put the wings and sauce on a flat piece of foil, instead of wrapping it up. Total mess, no sauce on the wings and they were over cooked. Not good.

The pizza looked good, but was about as bland as bland gets. The sauce was so sweet it overpowered the flavor of the toppings. Originally I thought the pizza was just gross, but then I ate the cheese and pepperoni separately and it was really good. So was the crust, but the sauce was comparable to a Subway Meatball sub when their sauce has been sitting all day. Ruined the whole pizza.

Maybe we just hit a bad day, because the reviews are really good. If it wasn’t a bad day, then all those who gave positive reviews have never had good pizza.

The order taker, cheese and pepperoni saved this from being 1 star. There has to be better...