Peter's New York Pizzeria — Restaurant in Town of Wolcott

Where to begin.....the pizza at best is mediocre, the sauce is the best part. The dough has a very pre-made texture. Order a cheese pizza and a sausage onion and peppers pizza. The cheese pizza was in the oven way too long and golden brown, not in a good way. The other pizza was just a very basic flavor. Then came the wings. Again nothing to write home about just a very plain style wing. Then here comes the 2 star review part, whoever was behind the counter at the time of pick up needs to have a lesson in respect, my wife went in the pay for the food and was asked about her order number, she didn't have it so she told him what the order was and the phone number. He gave her an attitude and told her the food wasn't ready yet which was already a longer wait than what we were told over the phone. Normally I look past that if they are busy but it didn't seem busy at the time.. Then as he was walking away to go into the back she explained to me that he mumbled under his breath that he can't stand females. So this sir is why your establishment gets 2 stars. Outside of the incredibly rude person working the counter the pizza was a 1 and done try. Had higher hopes but left...

Extremely disappointed!!! I've always got amazing pizza and wings from here!!! It was my moms birthday and she wanted pizza and wings...I grabbed a sheet pizza and 30 wings,half garlic parm half mild. Got home and it didnt even taste like pizza. The sauce tasted like it was bad. Something was definitely wrong with the sauce and the dough was super super hard. I had to get a steak knife to cut it!! Not to mention we all got sick a few hours later!! Puking and all the things. The wings seemed like they were double fried and didnt taste like garlic parm or mild at all. I called to just tell them and complain and the response I got was next time we will give you sauce on the side for your wings and when I tried to mention the pizza it was ok thank you and I got hung up on.This will be the last time I get food from there. For the amount of money I paid for that I would think they would of did something to help the situation and rectify it!! Nope!! And its a running thing because one of my friends have ordered a few times and have had the same experience with the wings and the pizza was poop. I never ever write a bad review but wow I...

my fiancé and i just recently moved out here 3 months ago, we been trying to find a pizza place out here we like and so far we only tried RayRays. We ordered Peter's one night for Chicken Finger subs and they were absolutely delicious. So then a week later on our weekly pizza night with our kids we decided to try your pizza considering how much we LOVED the subs... I have never been more disappointed in pizza before :( This pizza had the tiniest bit of sauce with the bare minimum of cheese and the crust and entire pizza was dry and solid. We all had a tough time chewing it... it tasted like cardboard and i'm not even normally one to complain. We ordered a sheet with wings and the ONLY thing good was the...