Lititz Pizza Company — Restaurant in Warwick Township

Most of the food I have had here has been good. Not amazing, but good. They offer solid pizza shop items and it is clean and has retro-modern appearance. I very much like places that make things fresh. Especially when they say “fresh”. I think things here are made to order… but I fear it’s becoming a “Sysco” menu. Meaning that many things on the menu are frozen and not made from scratch in house. Not just fried apps. But things like the “fresh grilled chicken” are just the faux grilled chicken slices that you can buy from a supplier like Tyson or Perdue in the supermarket.

When you say fresh grilled, it doesn’t have to be grilled on charcoal. But it should be a chunk of breast meat, seasoned and put on the grill/flattop. Not pulled out of a bag from Sysco or another food supplier, heated, and served.

I very truly hope that this business thrives. But making more things that are ready to heat from suppliers is often the death knell of a business.

Edit to add: I had a couple of chicken bolis. They both had a lot of chicken in them. But it was not fresh grilled chicken. It was ready-to-heat processed “grilled” chicken. The amount of money spent to put that much chicken in the bolis, I would guarantee is more costly than buying frozen breasts and cooking in house. So there’s a lot of meat, but it’s not great (or fresh grilled like listed) meat. So for these strombolis: Subpar experience, absolutely less profit margin for the business, and a couple of items I know not to...

Been here several times since I work close by. Overall I've mostly had good experiences. One bad so I bumped my review back to 4 stars. Ranch romano and margarita are my favorites.

Updated: stopped in for a quick lunch today. Ordered 2 slices, they only had one margarita so I ordered a plain also that was in the case. When they brought out the pizza, they clearly took pepperoni off a slice to make it plain. I had to trash it, was soggy and just not what I ordered. I would have appreciated if they came out and said they made a mistake and no longer had my slice, then offered for me to choose another instead of picking something off of another. 😡

Loved the ranch romano pizza I got. Knocked one star off because my fiance's order was wrong. Was supposed to be a cheesesteak but he got chicken instead. We were on limited time so he ate it anyway. We'll be back...

Absolutely amazing pizza! Even more incredible staff. I ordered pizza on a Saturday night at 6pm (prime time for dinner) and it took about an hour to get everything. That may sound like a long time, but honestly, that’s impressive for a new restaurant in Lititz on a Saturday during opening week.

Unfortunately I witnessed a gentlemen who thought that was too long of a wait and was very vocal about the fact it was “taking too long”. In my opinion the gentleman was out of line, but the staff was incredible and handled the situation perfectly.

Lititz has a decent pizza places and it’s great to see another great option. So do yourself a favor, order a pizza with a side of patience as this shop adapts to the rush.

Bravo Lititz Pizza Co. can’t wait for the next pizza!! Oh and...