Fratelli Pizza — Restaurant in West Wendover

So it hurts to leave this review as this place used to be my favorite, the food was great the staff was great, it was small but had a nice energy. I always felt welcomed by everyone there and the food was awesome...I'm not sure what happened but the restaurant got bigger (which excited me at first), they seemingly still cook everything in the og building and move it over to the new building. The new building is set up really weird, it's ment to be a full restaurant now but it's needs work (not really what I came here to talk about though). Since this update I hardly ever see the original people and when I do they don't say hi or anything (presumably busy with the new way things are) so I'm left to deal with these new workers and they are very cold and unfriendly, they take your money and send you away without much else. So the experience of going to grab a pizza lost the fun social aspect I loved of having a cool local pizza shop. Now to the food, since this change I've noticed the food hasn't been great, now they've had misses in the past but it was always just a random once in a blue moon kind of thing, I've gone a few times in the last few weeks and it's just not been good, and they seemingly changed their chicken and I'm not a fan. Again it hurts to release this but last night's meal was just horrible. I can't say I'll be going again for a while if ever , I miss how it used to be, I hope you guys get good business still, and fix up the interior of the restaurant because it looks like a Sims building that you just chucked a few pieces of...

I will say, it is not often I feel like I can actually give a 5 star review. This place takes the cake. We had a friendly greeting from the owner, Jeff whom we would learn over some amazing pizza, has lived a full life and clearly thoroughly enjoys hosting people. We enjoyed the conversation.

The pizzas were amazing. We had a build your own, Canadian bacon and pineapple with pepperoni and a small personal pizza for our 12 year old. She loved her small cheese pizza. I will say she’s not a huge cheese lover and she raved about this pizza. Ours was also nothing short of amazing. I’m not a fan of strong cheese flavor so I go with many salty and sweet toppings but Jeff’s cheese was not overpowering and had that amazing stretch every pizza should have. Jeff said it was hot coming out but honestly it was perfect eating temperature after just 5min . Spent less than $30 on pizzas for 3 and good beer for two- whoop whoop.

I’d like to also add this was one of few places open in the area around 7p midweek. I was hesitant bc being on vacation I thought I might want something else and not greasy pizza. I am so glad we stopped here. Both for the food and experience. It was great. Best of luck to Jeff and this pizzeria. Will come back if I’m ever...

UPDATE 2: visited again while visiting Wendover and the food was amazing! And they've expanded to add indoor seating and TV's with sports playing. This is a great place to stop!

UPDATE: Keeping 5 stars but didn't have the best experience this time. They called our name for food but we couldn't hear them cause the train was going by. Nobody bothered to come find us so our food sat there for 15 minutes while we wondered what was taking so long. We finally went to ask and it was sitting in a warming oven. The cheese bread was different and over cooked but still "ok". Pizza was good but not as great as our last few experiences. Hoping this was just a one off fail.

This place is fantastic! Everything feels homemade. The pizza is amazing, gotta get a pie. Their wings are very tender. Not super meaty but wow they have so much flavor and are so tender. Deserts are surprisingly great too. Tried 2, best is the salted caramel cheesecake. Best place in town, great outdoor seating, open...