Supreme Pizza & Subs — Restaurant in Whitman

🍕 SUPREME PIZZA MORE LIKE SUPREME RIP-OFF🍕 First this place is the most expensive pizza place in the AREA! Prices online differ from the in real life prices. $44.50 got us a total of 6 pieces of dried out buffalo chicken, ON 2 LARGE SUB rolls, 3 SMALL PIECES of chicken on each sub. It was like a bread sandwich!!! each sub is $12 and change. This is the worst place in WHITMAN AREA to get food. It's all teens working there that don't care. And then they short everything! they must be trained to skimp cuz it is bad!!! I'm talking worst I have seen! You want anything you gotta ask, no napkins. a large pizza from supreme weighs 3 pounds less then any other LOCAL LARGE PIZZA they skimp on dough and cheese... They skimp everything!!! $44.50 Even tipped the driver that couldn't even get out of his drivers seat to deliver the food lol (My wife already tipped with the card) So he sat in the driveway and called us to ask us "IF We wanted him to bring the food up!!" LOL 🍕$44.50 for 2 subs and a mozzarella stick. Think they charge delivery MAYBE prime time pricing idk maybe employees over charging and keeping the difference? Do not go to this place unless You wanna get ripped off... Don't believe Me go try it LoL they skimp big-time, and it's it's weirdly expensive.......Look at the other 5 reviews mentioning price and Food size...... 🤔

DON'T BELIEVE THE GOOD REVIEWS those reviews are most likely FAMILY and friends, and paid for with free food and local sports Sponsorships That's why it's hard to trust reviews in Small Town New England. This is not a place to feed a hungry family of 5... nope it's a place a construction worker goes for sub-par food because he's working close by. 🍕 ALL I KNOW IS THIS PLACE IS A...

This place is pretty good, all around. Most of the staff are courteous and friendly, especially the owners - some of the teen girl staff could use some lessons from them, but whatever. It doesn't stop me from ordering from them. I've been coming here for years and the food is consistent. They make the salads fresh when you order, the dressings are home made, they aren't skimpy with the subs, they use lean pastrami so you never get that fatty tendon mix that you can't chew, and the pizza is a cross between pub-style and pizza-house, but better than most of these pizza houses around here. The prices are what you'd expect to pay in this area and the quality is on point so that you don't feel you over paid. They're also usually pretty quick, unless they get slammed. Which is understandable, because they are a great place to get food from, everyone in Whitman knows it, and sometimes they all order at the same time. Anyways, this place is great, the staff is great and accommodating, the food is great - go on in and give them a shot. You...

The owners are very good at making you feel valued as a customer, and they seem to be highly involved and present. The subs are excellent... Both size and quality. I think the pizza is a bit small and over-priced, but again... Good quality. Since the expansion, the seating area is large yet cozy (very high booth seat backs). They keep it very clean and there is usually someone delivering food to tables, and that person usually clears any trash from your table and wipes down everything they walk by. Truly impressive for a pizza shop that has been around for a long time. They usually become complacent, but Supreme continues to keep the quality up, and the standards even...