The Bar Next Door — Restaurant in Windsor

Wow! Some places still do it right! I don’t know where to begin. The environment, the staff, the food. It has all the makings of a good night out.

This place is a diamond in the rough. The first time I went I saw pictures of their food online, and I was surprised when I pulled up to a restaurant attached to a Motel 8. Of course that didn’t stop us. Step inside and there are good tunes playing on the jukebox and a bartender (Marcus) welcoming us right away. The aesthetic is an interesting mix of a gamy dive bar with old pool tables and dart boards and some nice updates like flooring and light fixtures. It feels like it is a place that is both laid back and a place where management also takes pride in ownership obviously wanting everyone who comes through to enjoy themselves and be comfortable. It’s a great mix of old and new.

The staff here is a 10 out of 10. They are genuinely interested in you’re experience, and they know what they are doing. Marcus is a great bartender. He always has a special cocktail to suggest, and can whip up the classics perfectly. I think the young lady’s name is Amelia. She is a great server/bartender, and very sweet. Chad the GM is awesome. Remembers our drink orders and runs this place with pride. Pete the owner is hilarious and kind. He is usually in the back whipping up small miracles on the griddle, but stops out to mingle from time to time. Bottom line, the staff is amazing. It is also not their first rodeo. I suggest you read up on the story behind the Bar Next Door.

Last but definitely not least, the FOOD!!! Wow! We have purposely tried almost everything on the menu, and you can’t miss. As my girlfriend likes to say, “nothing but BANGERS on the the menu.” (She thinks she’s funny). Everything is interesting, unique, and most importantly delicious! The muscles are our favorite. The rueben egg rolls/wantons a close second. The burgers and fries are amazing too. Not your average bar burger. They have a delicious chicken sandwich , again not something you can find at Perkins. The list goes on, but the point is you can’t miss. Super fresh ingredients and amazing recipes. There cocktail list is an amazing compliment to the menu. Can’t miss here either. “Nothing but BANGERS!”

You have to check this place out. I tell all of my friends, and we go every weekend. If you pass this place up, you are missing out! Two thumbs up, five stars, a golden sticker, they are all...

Five Star and here is why...

Food: Starters; Muscles, Jersey Disco Fries and the Fried Cheese Curds. Probably one of my favorite starters here. I would grab the muscles as their white wine sauce is great! Muscle quality is great! As far as the cheese curds; honestly makes my top 3 places for cheese curds! This is a MUST! Elvis Jam Burger was great! Although I couldn’t really taste much peanut butter. This might be a good burger to try for those that want to try something out of the typical normal burger. Porchetta Sandwhich was good. Personally for me with pork I’d ideally like a little more sauce on it but for my fiancé he said he enjoyed it. Overall, still a good sandwhich!

Drinks: (21+) - Winter Solstice recommend a try! The infused ice cube is so unique! Taste was amazing!

Service: no complaints and everyone was just super friendly!

Overall atmosphere: Friendly bar and grill with the “better than your typical bar food” vibe.

Thanks guys! We will be back to try the...

Never did I expect that a restaurant attached to a Super 8 hotel in Windsor would be worth recommending—but The Bar Next Door completely changed my mind! This hidden gem delivers exceptional food, great service, and a unique atmosphere that rivals any standalone restaurant in town.

The smash burgers are packed with flavor, perfectly cooked, and downright addictive. The Reuben eggrolls are a creative twist that you must try, and the Nashville hot chicken sandwich hits the perfect balance of heat and flavor.

The vibe? Think high-end dive bar with a modern twist—welcoming, stylish, and perfect for a casual night out or a special bite to eat.

If you’re searching for the best bar food in or around DeForest or Windsor, a place with a fun atmosphere, or a local restaurant near Super 8 worth visiting, this is it. The Bar Next Door will exceed your expectations on every level....